School of Law, The Open University, UK.
Helena Kennedy Centre for International Justice, Law and Criminology Department, Sheffield Hallam University, UK.
Int J Law Psychiatry. 2019 Mar-Apr;63:76-84. doi: 10.1016/j.ijlp.2018.06.007. Epub 2018 Jul 8.
Although therapeutic jurisprudence ("TJ") is increasingly well-established internationally, particularly within the United States of America ("US"), to date it remains relatively unacknowledged within the United Kingdom ("UK"). This article will explore the opportunities presented within contemporary UK society for the greater promotion, and eventual mainstreaming, of TJ. It will also consider the challenges faced during this process and how best to overcome these. Its first key area of focus will be upon the potential role of legal education in the UK in educating law students (and academics) about TJ, considering which approaches are likely to be most effective in incorporating TJ perspectives, at what stage this should occur and to what extent TJ is likely to impact on the existing curricula at a time when proposed changes relating to entry into the legal profession are heavily influencing the work of Law Schools. The article will then move on to consider the receptiveness of the UK legal profession to the TJ paradigm in light of recent attempts to move to a competency-based approach to practice and to reconceptualise professionalism to meet the challenges of increasing fragmentation and corporatisation. The third key area it will explore is the UK's recent plans to reintroduce problem-solving courts ("PSCs") into its criminal justice system. The authors will discuss the downfall of the six UK Drug Court ("DC") pilots originally established in 2005 theorising upon their failures and reflecting upon whether the current UK criminal justice system is truly able to support a fresh round of PSC initiatives. The article will end with recommendations for ways in which the international TJ community should begin the process of mainstreaming TJ within the UK. It will conclude that there are currently significant opportunities to be utilised, but that this requires significant commitment and mobilisation amongst existing TJ scholars and practitioners.
尽管治疗法学(“TJ”)在国际上,特别是在美国(“US”),已经越来越成熟,但迄今为止,在英国(“UK”)仍然相对不为人知。本文将探讨当代英国社会为促进 TJ 更大发展并最终使其主流化所带来的机遇。它还将考虑在此过程中面临的挑战以及如何最好地克服这些挑战。它的第一个重点领域将是英国法律教育在向法律学生(和学者)传授 TJ 方面的潜在作用,考虑哪些方法最有可能有效地纳入 TJ 观点,应该在什么阶段进行,以及在拟议的与进入法律职业相关的改革对法学院工作产生重大影响的情况下,TJ 可能对现有课程产生多大影响。然后,文章将考虑英国法律界对 TJ 范式的接受程度,鉴于最近试图转向以能力为基础的实践方法,并重新构想专业精神以应对日益碎片化和公司化的挑战。它将探讨的第三个关键领域是英国最近计划在其刑事司法系统中重新引入解决问题法院(“PSC”)。作者将讨论最初于 2005 年设立的六个英国毒品法庭(“DC”)试点项目的失败,理论上分析其失败原因,并反思当前英国刑事司法系统是否真的能够支持新一轮的 PSC 倡议。文章将以 TJ 国际社区在英国主流化 TJ 方面应开始的建议结束。它将得出结论,目前有重大机遇可以利用,但这需要现有 TJ 学者和实践者的重大承诺和动员。