Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Winterthur, Switzerland.
University Hospital Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken). 2019 Jun;71(6):839-851. doi: 10.1002/acr.23705.
Vigorous cardiorespiratory training (CRT) in patients with axial spondyloarthritis (SpA) is effective, safe. and feasible; however, it has not yet been adopted in axial SpA exercise programs. Therefore, the aim of this study was to explore the barriers and facilitators for vigorous CRT among patients, physiotherapists, and rheumatologists.
Stakeholder-specific surveys were used to examine perceptions of barriers and facilitators to vigorous CRT, with categories organized according to the recommendations proposed by Grol and Wensing. Respondents chose the 3 most important barrier and facilitator categories and rated individual items on a 4-point scale. Frequencies and proportions were calculated, and ratings between active and inactive patients were compared.
Among all patients (n = 575 [response rate 34%]), the top 3 barrier categories were "low motivation" (n = 317 [59%]), "unsuccessful timing in daily routine" (n = 292 [55%]), and "hindering disease symptoms" (n = 272 [51%]). The top 3 facilitator categories were "high motivation" (n = 248 [47%]), "good organizational conditions" (n = 217 [41%]), and "facilitating disease symptoms" (n = 209 [40%]). More inactive patients than active patients chose "low motivation" as a barrier (P = 0.01). Among physiotherapists (n = 40 [response rate 48%]), the top 3 barrier categories were "heterogeneous groups" (n = 26 [70%]), "difficult organizational conditions" (n = 19 [51%]), and "low perceived motivation" (n = 19 [51%]). Among physiotherapists, the top 3 facilitator categories were "knowledge" (n = 20 [54%]), "homogeneous group composition," and "high perceived motivation" (both n = 17 [46%]). For rheumatologists (n = 73 [response rate 17%], with 54 [74%] answering barrier items and 68 [93%] answering facilitator items), the strongest barriers included "not enough information" (n = 25 [47%]) and "anticipated or perceived disinterest of patient" (n = 27 [50%]). The strongest facilitators reported by rheumatologists included "exercise important topic even in limited consultation time" (n = 65 [96%]) and "clear evidence for effectiveness of flexibility exercises" (n = 62 [91%]).
The identified facilitators and barriers will guide the development of stakeholder-specific implementation strategies.
剧烈的心肺训练(CRT)在患有中轴型脊柱关节炎(SpA)的患者中是有效、安全且可行的;然而,它尚未被纳入中轴型 SpA 的运动方案中。因此,本研究的目的是探讨患者、物理治疗师和风湿病医生进行剧烈 CRT 的障碍和促进因素。
采用利益相关者特定的调查来评估对剧烈 CRT 的障碍和促进因素的看法,根据 Grol 和 Wensing 提出的建议对类别进行组织。受访者选择 3 个最重要的障碍和促进因素类别,并对 4 分制的个别项目进行评分。计算频率和比例,并比较活跃患者和不活跃患者之间的评分。
在所有患者(n = 575[回应率 34%])中,排名前 3 的障碍类别是“低动机”(n = 317[55%])、“日常时间安排不成功”(n = 292[55%])和“阻碍疾病症状”(n = 272[51%])。排名前 3 的促进因素类别是“高动机”(n = 248[47%])、“良好的组织条件”(n = 217[41%])和“促进疾病症状”(n = 209[40%])。与活跃患者相比,更多的不活跃患者选择“低动机”作为障碍(P = 0.01)。在物理治疗师中(n = 40[回应率 48%]),排名前 3 的障碍类别是“异质群体”(n = 26[70%])、“困难的组织条件”(n = 19[51%])和“低感知动机”(n = 19[51%])。在物理治疗师中,排名前 3 的促进因素类别是“知识”(n = 20[54%])、“同质群体组成”和“高感知动机”(均为 n = 17[46%])。对于风湿病医生(n = 73[回应率 17%],其中 54[74%]回答了障碍项目,68[93%]回答了促进因素项目),最强的障碍包括“信息不足”(n = 25[47%])和“预期或感知到患者的不感兴趣”(n = 27[50%])。风湿病医生报告的最强促进因素包括“即使在有限的咨询时间内,运动也是一个重要的话题”(n = 65[96%])和“柔韧性锻炼的明确有效性证据”(n = 62[91%])。
确定的障碍和促进因素将指导制定针对特定利益相关者的实施策略。