Graduate School of Public Health, Seoul National University, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Department of Global Environmental Health, School of Public Health, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan.
Environ Int. 2018 Oct;119:379-387. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2018.06.020. Epub 2018 Jul 9.
Many previous literatures suggested that high temperature and diurnal temperature range (DTR) are prominent risk factors to increase risk of mortality. However, the role of effect modification of temperature on the DTR-related mortality is unclear. We examined whether temperature was an effect modifier on the DTR-mortality association and how the modification patterns differed by cause of deaths and different regional climates using a nationwide 47 prefecture data in Japan (1972-2015). We used a two-stage analysis. For the first stage, we used a time-series regression with a distributed lag model to estimate the DTR-mortality association according to five levels of temperature (extreme cold, cold, moderate, hot, and extreme hot days) for each prefecture stratified by twelve cause-specific deaths. Then, we applied a meta-analysis to pool the estimates across the 47 prefectures in Japan and separately by cooler vs. warmer regions. Our findings showed that the risk of mortality associated with DTR was strongly modified by temperature for all causes and cardiovascular deaths (p < 0.001) in the total population, suggesting that the influence of DTR on mortality increases at higher levels of temperature. These findings were consistent across warmer and cooler regions. Similar patterns were observed for respiratory and renal disease deaths which demonstrated the associations with DTR were the highest during extreme hot days, although it was statistically not significant and varied depending on the climate regions. Our findings suggest that the DTR-related mortality may be modified by daily mean temperature and the most elevated during extremely hot temperatures.
许多先前的文献表明,高温和日较差(DTR)是增加死亡率风险的突出危险因素。然而,温度对 DTR 相关死亡率的影响修饰作用尚不清楚。我们研究了温度是否是 DTR-死亡率关联的效应修饰因子,以及这种修饰模式如何因死因和不同区域气候而异,使用了日本全国 47 个县的数据(1972-2015 年)。我们采用两阶段分析。在第一阶段,我们使用时间序列回归和分布滞后模型,根据每个县 12 种特定死因的 5 个温度水平(极寒、寒冷、温和、炎热和极热天气),对每个县的 DTR-死亡率关联进行估计。然后,我们对日本 47 个县的估计值进行荟萃分析,并分别对较凉爽和较温暖地区进行分析。我们的研究结果表明,在全人群中,DTR 与死亡率的关联受到温度的强烈修饰,所有原因和心血管死亡(p<0.001),这表明 DTR 对死亡率的影响在较高温度下增加。这些发现在较凉爽和较温暖地区都一致。呼吸和肾脏疾病死亡的类似模式也得到了观察,表明 DTR 与这些疾病的关联在极热天气时最高,尽管这在统计学上并不显著,并且因气候区域而异。我们的研究结果表明,DTR 相关死亡率可能受到日平均温度的修饰,并且在极高温度下最为显著。