Department of Public Health, Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
The Norwegian Centre for Migrant and Minority Health Research, Oslo, Norway.
PLoS One. 2018 Jul 16;13(7):e0200681. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0200681. eCollection 2018.
Intervention trials and guidelines for the prevention of type 2 diabetes (T2D) in populations of South Asian origin often include strategies to improve diet and physical activity that are based on those developed for other populations. These may be suboptimal for the South Asian target populations. We aimed to provide an overview of included recommended dietary and physical activity components, and to identify whether these were supported by evidence of their effectiveness. Databases were searched until September 2017 for intervention studies and guidelines with an adult South Asian population without T2D. The protocol was registered in PROSPERO, registration number: CRD42015207067. The quality of included studies and guidelines was assessed. Dietary and physical activity components, and effects on T2D incidence, glycemic status and adiposity measures, were summarized in tabular format and evaluated narratively. Eighteen intervention studies and four guidelines were identified. Dietary and physical activity components were similar to recommendations for the general population. Intervention studies and guidelines did not reference evidence to support the effectiveness of components included in the intervention for South Asian populations in particular. Moreover, we were unable to assess patterns of components to determine the effects of specific components. Evaluation of current and emerging components among South Asian populations and subgroups seems necessary to formulate more specific recommendations in future intervention studies and guidelines.
干预试验和预防南亚裔人群 2 型糖尿病(T2D)的指南通常包括改善饮食和身体活动的策略,这些策略是基于为其他人群制定的策略。这些策略可能不适合南亚目标人群。我们旨在提供所纳入的推荐饮食和身体活动成分的概述,并确定这些成分是否得到其有效性证据的支持。截至 2017 年 9 月,我们在没有 T2D 的成年南亚人群中搜索了干预研究和指南。该方案在 PROSPERO 中进行了注册,注册号:CRD42015207067。我们评估了纳入研究和指南的质量。以表格形式总结了饮食和身体活动成分以及对 T2D 发病率、血糖状况和肥胖测量的影响,并进行了叙述性评估。确定了 18 项干预研究和 4 项指南。饮食和身体活动成分与一般人群的建议相似。干预研究和指南没有引用证据来支持针对南亚人群的干预措施中包含的成分的有效性。此外,我们无法评估成分的模式来确定特定成分的影响。评估南亚人群和亚组中当前和新兴的成分似乎是制定未来干预研究和指南中更具体建议的必要条件。