Abdel Razek Ahmed Abdel Khalek, Elrakhawy Mohamed Magdy, Yossof Mahmoud Mohamed, Nageb Hadeer Mohamed
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Mansoura Faculty of Medicine, Mansoura, Egypt.
Department of cardiology, Mansoura Faculty of Medicine, Mansoura, Egypt.
Pol J Radiol. 2018 Apr 16;83:e151-e159. doi: 10.5114/pjr.2018.75641. eCollection 2018.
To assess inter-observer variability of the Coronary Artery Disease - Reporting and Data System (CAD-RADS) for classifying the degree of coronary artery stenosis in patients with stable chest pain.
A prospective study was conducted upon 96 patients with coronary artery disease, who underwent coronary computed tomography angiography (CTA). The images were classified using the CAD-RAD system according to the degree of stenosis, the presence of a modifier: graft (G), stent (S), vulnerable plaque (V), or non-diagnostic (n) and the associated coronary anomalies, and non-coronary cardiac and extra-cardiac findings. Image analysis was performed by two reviewers. Inter-observer agreement was assessed.
There was excellent inter-observer agreement for CAD-RADS ( = 0.862), at 88.5%. There was excellent agreement for CAD-RADS 0 ( = 1.0), CAD-RADS 1 ( = 0.92), CAD-RADS 3 ( = 0.808), CAD-RADS 4 ( = 0.826), and CAD-RADS 5 ( = 0.833) and good agreement for CAD-RADS 2 ( = 0.76). There was excellent agreement for modifier G ( = 1.0) and modifier S ( = 1.0), good agreement for modifier N ( = 0.79), and moderate agreement for modifier V ( = 0.59). There was excellent agreement for associated coronary artery anomalies ( = 0.845), non-coronary cardiac findings ( = 0.857), and extra-cardiac findings ( = 0.81).
There is inter-observer agreement of CAD-RADS in categorising the degree of coronary arteries stenosis, and the modifier of the system and associated cardiac and extra-cardiac findings.
评估冠状动脉疾病报告和数据系统(CAD-RADS)在对稳定型胸痛患者冠状动脉狭窄程度进行分类时观察者间的变异性。
对96例接受冠状动脉计算机断层扫描血管造影(CTA)的冠心病患者进行了一项前瞻性研究。根据狭窄程度、是否存在修饰词(移植物(G)、支架(S)、易损斑块(V)或非诊断性(n))以及相关冠状动脉异常、非冠状动脉心脏和心脏外表现,使用CAD-RAD系统对图像进行分类。由两名观察者进行图像分析。评估观察者间的一致性。
CAD-RADS观察者间一致性极佳(=0.862),为88.5%。CAD-RADS 0(=1.0)、CAD-RADS 1(=0.92)、CAD-RADS 3(=0.808)、CAD-RADS 4(=0.826)和CAD-RADS 5(=0.833)一致性极佳,CAD-RADS 2(=0.76)一致性良好。修饰词G(=1.0)和修饰词S(=1.0)一致性极佳,修饰词N(=0.79)一致性良好,修饰词V(=0.59)一致性中等。相关冠状动脉异常(=0.845)、非冠状动脉心脏表现(=0.857)和心脏外表现(=0.81)一致性极佳。
CAD-RADS在对冠状动脉狭窄程度、系统修饰词以及相关心脏和心脏外表现进行分类时存在观察者间一致性。