Wajekar Anjana S, Salgaonkar Sweta V, Chincholi Indrani H, Shetty Anita N
Department of Anaesthesia, KEM Hospital, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
Indian J Anaesth. 2018 Jul;62(7):502-508. doi: 10.4103/ija.IJA_98_18.
Research is an integral component of medical education and practice. However, the art of medical writing remains neglected. Case report writing marks foray into the world of publications and presentations. We assessed and compared the impact of basic medical writing workshop about case report writing and their perception levels of confidence in these skills, among post-graduate anaesthesia students.
A needs assessment for medical writing skills was performed among all anaesthesia residents. A total of 20 students were enrolled in this study. The pre-workshop assignment consisted of writing one case report per participant within 30 days, followed by students' confidence assessment in these skills. A workshop on basic medical writing including analytical writing, scientific writing and plagiarism were conducted. Post-workshop a similar assignment was provided, followed by students' confidence assessment.
Moderate-to-high need for help was felt by 92.63% for analytical skills, 100% for scientific skills and writing without plagiarism, 95.78% for overall writing skills. For case report writing, the analytical and scientific writing significantly improved after the workshop ( = 0.01 and = 0.016, respectively). There was a significant improvement in the students' confidence levels post-workshop in their analytical writing skills, avoiding plagiarism and overall writing capabilities ( = 0.02, = 0.016 and = 0.002, respectively).
Writing skills of participants and their confidence in these skills improved post-workshop.
研究是医学教育与实践不可或缺的组成部分。然而,医学写作的技巧仍被忽视。病例报告写作标志着进入出版物和展示的领域。我们评估并比较了基础医学写作工作坊对病例报告写作的影响,以及研究生麻醉专业学生对这些技能的自信程度。
对所有麻醉住院医师进行医学写作技能的需求评估。本研究共招募了20名学生。工作坊前的任务包括每位参与者在30天内撰写一份病例报告,随后对学生在这些技能方面的自信程度进行评估。举办了一个关于基础医学写作的工作坊,包括分析性写作、科学性写作和剽窃问题。工作坊后布置了类似的任务,随后进行学生自信程度评估。
92.63%的学生认为在分析技能方面有中等到高度的帮助需求,100%的学生认为在科学技能、无剽窃写作方面有需求,95.78%的学生认为在整体写作技能方面有需求。对于病例报告写作,工作坊后分析性写作和科学性写作有显著提高(分别为P = 0.01和P = 0.016)。工作坊后学生在分析性写作技能、避免剽窃和整体写作能力方面的自信程度有显著提高(分别为P = 0.02、P = 0.016和P = 0.002)。
参与者的写作技能及其对这些技能的自信程度在工作坊后有所提高。