Berzins Kathryn, Louch Gemma, Brown Mark, O'Hara Jane K, Baker John
School of Healthcare, University of Leeds, Baines Wing, Woodhouse Lane, Leeds, LS29JT, UK.
Yorkshire Quality and Safety Research Group, Yorkshire & Humber Patient Safety Translational Research Centre, Bradford Institute for Health Research, Temple Bank House, Bradford Royal Infirmary, Duckworth Lane, Bradford, BD9 6RJ, UK.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2018 Aug 17;18(1):644. doi: 10.1186/s12913-018-3455-5.
Previous research into improving patient safety has emphasised the importance of responding to and learning from concerns raised by service users and carers. Expertise gained by the experiences of service users and their carers has also been seen as a potential resource to improve patient safety. We know little about the ease of raising concerns within mental health services, and the potential benefits of involving service users and carers in safety interventions. This study aimed to explore service user and carer perceptions of raising safety concerns, and service user, carer and health professional views on the potential for service user and carer involvement in safety interventions.
UK service users, carers and health professionals ( n= 185) were recruited via social media to a cross-sectional survey focussed on raising concerns about safety issues and views on potential service user and carer participation in safety interventions. Data were analysed using descriptive statistics, and free text responses were coded into categories.
The sample of 185 participants included 90 health professionals, 77 service users and 18 carers. Seventy seven percent of service users and carers reported finding it very difficult or difficult to raise concerns. Their most frequently cited barriers to raising concerns were: services did not listen; concerns about repercussions; and the process of raising concerns, especially while experiencing mental ill health. There was universal support from health professionals for service user and carer involvement in safety interventions and over half the service users and carers supported involvement, primarily due to their expertise from experience.
Mental health service users and carers experience difficulties in raising safety concerns meaning that potentially useful information is being missed. All the health professionals and the majority of service users and carers saw potential for service users and carer involvement in interventions to improve safety, to ensure their experiences are taken into consideration. The results provide guidance for future research about the most effective ways of ensuring that concerns about safety can be both raised and responded to, and how service user and carer involvement in improving safety in mental health care can be further developed.
先前关于提高患者安全的研究强调了回应服务使用者和护理者提出的问题并从中学习的重要性。服务使用者及其护理者的经验所积累的专业知识也被视为提高患者安全的潜在资源。我们对在精神卫生服务中提出问题的难易程度,以及让服务使用者和护理者参与安全干预措施的潜在益处了解甚少。本研究旨在探讨服务使用者和护理者对提出安全问题的看法,以及服务使用者、护理者和卫生专业人员对服务使用者和护理者参与安全干预措施可能性的看法。
通过社交媒体招募了英国的服务使用者、护理者和卫生专业人员(n = 185),进行一项横断面调查,重点是对安全问题提出关切以及对服务使用者和护理者参与安全干预措施的看法。使用描述性统计分析数据,并将自由文本回复编码分类。
185名参与者的样本包括90名卫生专业人员、77名服务使用者和18名护理者。77%的服务使用者和护理者表示发现提出关切非常困难或困难。他们提出关切时最常提到的障碍是:服务机构不听;担心后果;以及提出关切的过程,尤其是在患有精神疾病期间。卫生专业人员普遍支持服务使用者和护理者参与安全干预措施,超过一半的服务使用者和护理者支持参与,主要是因为他们的经验专业知识。
精神卫生服务使用者和护理者在提出安全关切方面遇到困难,这意味着可能会错过潜在有用的信息。所有卫生专业人员以及大多数服务使用者和护理者都认为服务使用者和护理者有可能参与改善安全的干预措施,以确保他们的经验得到考虑。研究结果为未来研究提供了指导,即如何以最有效的方式确保能够提出并回应安全关切,以及如何进一步发展服务使用者和护理者参与改善精神卫生保健安全的情况。