Pacific Consultants Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan.
Disaster Prevention Research Institute, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan.
Risk Anal. 2018 Nov;38(11):2424-2440. doi: 10.1111/risa.13144. Epub 2018 Aug 20.
This research formulates a dynamic stochastic macroeconomic model that includes an optimization problem for the formation of stock of human capital, production capital, and household assets, and quantitatively examines economic impacts of disaster on developing countries. We further investigate the optimal policy of development of disaster risk reduction (DRR) capital by considering costs of DRR investment, and show that the effect of DRR investment on economic growth is like a single-peaked curve with respect to the DRR investment rate, which implies that overaccumulation could decelerate economic growth. Moreover, this study emphasizes an effect that DRR capital increases the shadow values of other types of capital and assets by reducing risks of destruction. Importantly, this effect emerges even in cases of process, in which disaster does not actually occur for a long period. We decompose the effects of DRR investments into two parts: "ex-ante risk reduction effect" (ARRE) and "ex-post damage mitigation effect" (PDME). Furthermore, we develop a method of measuring ARRE and PDME by applying the results of Monte Carlo simulation, and show that the scale of ARRE is nonnegligible using a case study of Pakistan. The results imply that types of models that cannot valuate ARRE underestimate the value of DRR investment.
本研究构建了一个动态随机宏观经济模型,其中包括人力资本存量、生产资本和家庭资产形成的最优化问题,并定量考察了灾害对发展中国家的经济影响。我们进一步研究了考虑灾害风险管理(DRR)投资成本的最优 DRR 资本发展政策,并表明 DRR 投资对经济增长的影响与 DRR 投资率呈单峰曲线关系,这意味着过度积累可能会减缓经济增长。此外,本研究强调了 DRR 资本通过降低破坏风险,增加其他类型资本和资产的影子价值的效果。重要的是,即使在很长一段时间内实际上没有发生灾害的情况下,这种效果也会出现。我们将 DRR 投资的效果分解为两部分:“事前风险降低效果”(ARRE)和“事后损害缓解效果”(PDME)。此外,我们通过应用蒙特卡罗模拟的结果,开发了一种衡量 ARRE 和 PDME 的方法,并通过对巴基斯坦的案例研究表明,ARRE 的规模不可忽视。结果表明,不能对 ARRE 进行估值的模型类型低估了 DRR 投资的价值。