Ashworth Emma, Demkowicz Ola, Lendrum Ann, Frearson Kirsty
Institute of Education, University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester, UK.
School Ment Health. 2018;10(3):287-300. doi: 10.1007/s12310-018-9282-3. Epub 2018 Jul 2.
There has been increased interest in recent years regarding the utility of imported universal prevention and promotion (P&P) programmes in UK schools, many of which have a coaching model attached. However, there have been relatively few studies exploring the cultural transferability and social validity of these models, even though evidence suggests that these factors are important to the successful implementation of the programmes, and thus the achievement of the intended outcomes. The aim of the current study was to explore the coaching practices that teachers report experiencing, and to further understanding of the perceived benefits of these coaching practices to teachers. The sample consisted of 33 teachers implementing one of two universal, school-based P&P programmes, and as part of large-scale, randomised controlled trials. Qualitative, semi-structured interviews were conducted, and data were analysed thematically utilising a hybrid approach. Teachers typically reported engaging in six distinct practices with their coaches. While the majority of these practices were in line with coaching literature, there were some discrepancies between intended coaching practices and teachers' reports. The coaching practices were generally perceived to be acceptable to teachers. Two unanticipated practices, and , appeared to be of particular value to teachers, although these are not currently a prominent feature in existing coaching models. The findings provide implications for improving the development of socially valid coaching models for UK schools.
近年来,人们对英国学校引进的通用预防与促进(P&P)项目的效用越来越感兴趣,其中许多项目都附有指导模式。然而,尽管有证据表明这些因素对项目的成功实施以及预期成果的实现很重要,但探索这些模式的文化可转移性和社会效度的研究相对较少。本研究的目的是探讨教师报告的所经历的指导实践,并进一步了解这些指导实践对教师的感知益处。样本包括33名实施两项通用的、基于学校的P&P项目之一的教师,且是作为大规模随机对照试验的一部分。进行了定性的半结构化访谈,并采用混合方法对数据进行了主题分析。教师通常报告与他们的教练进行了六种不同的实践。虽然这些实践中的大多数与指导文献一致,但预期的指导实践与教师的报告之间存在一些差异。这些指导实践总体上被教师认为是可以接受的。两种意外的实践,即[此处原文缺失两种实践的具体内容],对教师似乎具有特别的价值,尽管这些目前并不是现有指导模式的显著特征。这些发现为改进英国学校具有社会效度的指导模式的发展提供了启示。