Clinic for Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, University Medical Center Gottingen, Gottingen, Germany.
Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, TU Dresden, Germany.
Curr Neuropharmacol. 2019;17(8):703-709. doi: 10.2174/1570159X16666180828095131.
While Behavioral Therapy (BT) should be recommended as the first step in the treatment of OCD as well as TS, medication can be added for augmentation and in certain situations (e.g. family preference, BT not available or feasible) the priority may even reverse. This narrative review is given on the complexity of drug treatment in patients comorbid with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and Tourette syndrome (TS) and other tic problems. OCD with TS is a co-occurring combination of the two generally delimitable, but in detail, also overlapping disorders which wax and wane with time but have different courses as well as necessities and options of treatment. Distinct subtypes like "tic-related OCD" are questionable. Obsessive-compulsive symptoms (OCS) and tics are frequently associated (OCS in TS up to 90%, tics in OCD up to 37%). Sensory-motor phenomena like urges and just-right feelings reflect some behavioral overlap. The main additional psychopathologies are attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), mood problems and anxiety. Also, hair pulling disorder and skin picking disorder are related to OCD with TS. Hence, the assessment and drug treatment of its many psychopathological problems need high clinical experience, careful planning, and ongoing evaluation/adaptation. Drugs are able to reduce clinical symptoms but cannot cure the disorders, which should be treated in parallel in their own right; i.e. for OCD serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRI) and for TS (tics), certain antipsychotics can be successfully prescribed. In cases of OCD with tics, when OCS responds only partially, an augmentation with antipsychotics (recommended: risperidone and aripiprazole) may improve OCS as well as tics. Also, the benzamide sulpiride, an atypical antipsychotics, may be beneficial in treating the combination of OCS, tics and anxious-depressive problems. Probably, any additional psychopathologies of OCD might attenuate the effectiveness of SSRI on OCS; on the other hand, in cases of OCD with tics, SSRI may reduce not only OCS but also stress sensitivity and emotional problems and thus leading to better selfregulatory abilities, useful to improve tic suppression. In sum, some clinical guidance can be given, but there remain many uncertainties because of a scarce database for psychopharmacotherapy in OCD with TS.
虽然行为疗法 (BT) 应该被推荐作为治疗强迫症和 TS 的第一步,但药物治疗可以作为增强手段,并且在某些情况下(例如,家庭偏好、BT 不可用或不可行),治疗优先级甚至可能会反转。本文就共病强迫症 (OCD) 和妥瑞氏症 (TS) 及其他抽动问题的患者药物治疗的复杂性进行综述。OCD 伴 TS 是两种通常可界定、但在细节上也存在重叠的疾病同时发生的组合,其随时间而变化,但具有不同的病程以及治疗的必要性和选择。像“与抽动相关的强迫症”这样的不同亚型是值得怀疑的。强迫症状 (OCS) 和抽动经常同时出现(TS 中的 OCS 高达 90%,OCD 中的抽动高达 37%)。感觉运动现象,如冲动和恰到好处的感觉,反映了一些行为上的重叠。主要的附加精神病理学问题是注意缺陷多动障碍 (ADHD)、情绪问题和焦虑。此外,拔毛障碍和皮肤搔抓障碍也与 OCD 伴 TS 有关。因此,其许多精神病理学问题的评估和药物治疗需要丰富的临床经验、仔细的规划以及持续的评估/调整。药物能够减轻临床症状,但不能治愈这些疾病,这些疾病应该根据其自身的特点进行平行治疗;即对于 OCD,使用选择性 5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂 (SSRI),对于 TS(抽动),使用某些抗精神病药物。对于伴有抽动的 OCD,当 OCS 仅部分反应时,用抗精神病药物(推荐:利培酮和阿立哌唑)进行增强治疗可能会改善 OCS 和抽动。此外,苯甲酰胺舒必利,一种非典型抗精神病药物,可能对治疗 OCS、抽动和焦虑抑郁问题的组合有益。可能 OCD 的任何其他附加精神病理学问题都会降低 SSRI 对 OCS 的有效性;另一方面,在伴有抽动的 OCD 中,SSRI 不仅可以减少 OCS,还可以减轻应激敏感性和情绪问题,从而提高自我调节能力,有助于改善抽动抑制。总之,可以提供一些临床指导,但由于 OCD 伴 TS 的精神药理学治疗数据库有限,仍存在许多不确定性。