Herrin Jeph, Harris Kathleen G, Spatz Erica, Cobbs-Lomax Darcey, Allen Sharon, León Tomás
Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf. 2018 Sep;44(9):545-551. doi: 10.1016/j.jcjq.2018.03.008. Epub 2018 Jul 3.
Diversity in hospital leadership is often valued as important for achieving clinical excellence. The American Hospital Association surveyed hospitals about their actions to identify and address health disparities. The survey asked about the degree of representation of racial and ethnic minorities and women among executives and board members.
The survey contained 78 items in four domains: Leadership and Strategic Planning, Workforce, Data Collection, and Reducing Disparities. All items were standardized and pooled within each domain to construct four variables. Logistic regression models were used to assess the difference in domain scores, for each domain, between hospitals with (a) high and low representation of people of color in the C-suite, (b) high and low representation of women in the corporate (C-) suite, (c) high and low representation of people of color on the board, and (d) high and low representation of women on the board.
Hospitals with more diverse boards with respect to race and ethnicity had significantly higher scores for all domains, indicating that these hospitals were pursuing substantially more strategies in all domains. In contrast, more racially and ethnically diverse executive suites were associated only with the Data Collection domain, while hospitals with a higher percentage of women in executive positions had lower scores for all domains except Data Collection.
Hospitals with greater representation of racial and ethnic minorities in leadership positions had greater commitments to diversity initiatives. However, hospitals with women-particularly white women-in leadership positions reported fewer diversity initiatives. Future research is needed to examine the mechanisms and causality behind these associations.
医院领导层的多元化通常被认为对实现卓越临床水平至关重要。美国医院协会对医院为识别和解决健康差异所采取的行动进行了调查。该调查询问了高管和董事会成员中种族和族裔少数群体以及女性的代表程度。
该调查包含四个领域的78个项目:领导力与战略规划、员工队伍、数据收集和减少差异。所有项目均进行了标准化处理,并在每个领域内进行汇总以构建四个变量。使用逻辑回归模型评估在以下方面,各领域得分在不同医院之间的差异:(a)高管层中有色人种代表比例高和低的医院;(b)公司(高管)层中女性代表比例高和低的医院;(c)董事会中有色人种代表比例高和低的医院;(d)董事会中女性代表比例高和低的医院。
在种族和族裔方面董事会更加多元化的医院,在所有领域的得分都显著更高,这表明这些医院在所有领域都在推行更多的策略。相比之下,高管层在种族和族裔方面更加多元化仅与数据收集领域相关,而高管职位中女性比例较高的医院,除数据收集领域外,在所有领域的得分都较低。
领导层中种族和族裔少数群体代表比例更高的医院,对多元化举措的投入更大。然而,领导层中有女性——尤其是白人女性——的医院,所报告的多元化举措较少。需要未来的研究来探究这些关联背后的机制和因果关系。