van den Boer Janet, van der Lee Annemiek, Zhou Lingchuan, Papapanagiotou Vasileios, Diou Christos, Delopoulos Anastasios, Mars Monica
Sensory Science and Eating Behaviour Chair Group, Division of Human Nutrition, Wageningen University, Wageningen, Netherlands.
Electronics & Firmware, Systems Division, Centre Suisse d'Electronique et de Microtechnique, Neuchâtel, Switzerland.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2018 Sep 4;6(9):e170. doi: 10.2196/mhealth.9781.
The available methods for monitoring food intake-which for a great part rely on self-report-often provide biased and incomplete data. Currently, no good technological solutions are available. Hence, the SPLENDID eating detection sensor (an ear-worn device with an air microphone and a photoplethysmogram [PPG] sensor) was developed to enable complete and objective measurements of eating events. The technical performance of this device has been described before. To date, literature is lacking a description of how such a device is perceived and experienced by potential users.
The objective of our study was to explore how potential users perceive and experience the SPLENDID eating detection sensor.
Potential users evaluated the eating detection sensor at different stages of its development: (1) At the start, 12 health professionals (eg, dieticians, personal trainers) were interviewed and a focus group was held with 5 potential end users to find out their thoughts on the concept of the eating detection sensor. (2) Then, preliminary prototypes of the eating detection sensor were tested in a laboratory setting where 23 young adults reported their experiences. (3) Next, the first wearable version of the eating detection sensor was tested in a semicontrolled study where 22 young, overweight adults used the sensor on 2 separate days (from lunch till dinner) and reported their experiences. (4) The final version of the sensor was tested in a 4-week feasibility study by 20 young, overweight adults who reported their experiences.
Throughout all the development stages, most individuals were enthusiastic about the eating detection sensor. However, it was stressed multiple times that it was critical that the device be discreet and comfortable to wear for a longer period. In the final study, the eating detection sensor received an average grade of 3.7 for wearer comfort on a scale of 1 to 10. Moreover, experienced discomfort was the main reason for wearing the eating detection sensor <2 hours a day. The participants reported having used the eating detection sensor on 19/28 instructed days on average.
The SPLENDID eating detection sensor, which uses an air microphone and a PPG sensor, is a promising new device that can facilitate the collection of reliable food intake data, as shown by its technical potential. Potential users are enthusiastic, but to be successful wearer comfort and discreetness of the device need to be improved.
现有的食物摄入量监测方法在很大程度上依赖自我报告,往往会提供有偏差且不完整的数据。目前,尚无良好的技术解决方案。因此,研发了SPLENDID饮食检测传感器(一种带有空气麦克风和光电容积脉搏波描记法[PPG]传感器的耳部佩戴设备),以实现对进食事件的完整和客观测量。该设备的技术性能此前已有描述。迄今为止,文献中缺乏关于潜在用户如何看待和体验这种设备的描述。
我们研究的目的是探讨潜在用户如何看待和体验SPLENDID饮食检测传感器。
潜在用户在该饮食检测传感器研发的不同阶段对其进行了评估:(1)一开始,对12名健康专业人员(如营养师、私人教练)进行了访谈,并与5名潜在最终用户进行了焦点小组讨论,以了解他们对饮食检测传感器概念的看法。(2)然后,在实验室环境中对饮食检测传感器的初步原型进行了测试,23名年轻人报告了他们的体验。(3)接下来,在一项半控制研究中对饮食检测传感器的首个可穿戴版本进行了测试,22名年轻超重成年人在两个不同的日子(从午餐到晚餐)使用该传感器,并报告了他们的体验。(4)在一项为期4周的可行性研究中,20名年轻超重成年人对传感器的最终版本进行了测试,并报告了他们的体验。
在所有研发阶段,大多数人对饮食检测传感器都很感兴趣。然而,多次强调该设备必须隐蔽且佩戴起来长时间舒适至关重要。在最终研究中,饮食检测传感器在佩戴舒适度方面的平均评分为3.7(满分10分)。此外,体验到的不适是每天佩戴饮食检测传感器少于2小时的主要原因。参与者报告平均在28个指定日期中的19天使用了饮食检测传感器。
使用空气麦克风和PPG传感器的SPLENDID饮食检测传感器是一种很有前景的新设备,从其技术潜力来看,它可以促进可靠食物摄入量数据的收集。潜在用户对此很感兴趣,但要取得成功,该设备的佩戴舒适度和隐蔽性需要改进。