Karnad Aditi, Pannelay Annie, Boshnakova Anelia, Lovell Alan D, Cook Robert G
The Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU), London, UK,
Risk Manag Healthc Policy. 2018 Aug 22;11:117-125. doi: 10.2147/RMHP.S163439. eCollection 2018.
Stroke is a leading cause of death and disability, although studies show that 90% of strokes can be prevented. The evidence base for stroke prevention is well established, and this study aimed to investigate how well European countries are adopting the European Society of Cardiology (ESC) guidelines, particularly toward implementation of the recommended best practice in stroke prevention.
We developed a stroke prevention scorecard - populated with World Health Organization (WHO) data, secondary research, time-series data, and a survey of 550 physicians - to benchmark 11 European countries in the context of the ESC guidelines.
All countries were found to have policies in place to manage general behavioral risk factors of noncommunicable disease (NCD), but we found that more needs to be done to address cardiovascular disease - specifically, stroke risk factors. Although ten of the countries in this study endorse the ESC cardiovascular clinical guidelines, implementation is lacking. Eight out of the 11 countries received the lowest score in regard to raising awareness around stroke, and 7 countries were found not to have a stroke registry. Among physicians surveyed in primary care it was reported that less than 30% of patients over 40 years old were screened for blood pressure, whereas even fewer were screened for atrial fibrillation; in 10 out of the 11 countries, less than 20% of patients over 65 years old were screened for atrial fibrillation.
Although progress is being made in managing the burden of NCDs, our findings reveal opportunities for improvement in the primary prevention of stroke. Further developments in strategic planning, raising awareness, and monitoring disease are required, as is research on barriers to the implementation of best practice screening of blood pressure and atrial fibrillation in primary care.
中风是导致死亡和残疾的主要原因,尽管研究表明90%的中风是可以预防的。中风预防的证据基础已得到充分确立,本研究旨在调查欧洲国家在采用欧洲心脏病学会(ESC)指南方面的情况,特别是在中风预防方面推荐的最佳实践的实施情况。
我们制定了一份中风预防记分卡,其中包含世界卫生组织(WHO)的数据、二次研究、时间序列数据以及对550名医生的调查,以便在ESC指南的背景下对11个欧洲国家进行基准评估。
发现所有国家都制定了管理非传染性疾病(NCD)一般行为风险因素的政策,但我们发现,在解决心血管疾病(特别是中风风险因素)方面仍有更多工作要做。尽管本研究中的10个国家认可ESC心血管临床指南,但在实施方面仍存在不足。11个国家中有8个在提高中风意识方面得分最低,7个国家没有中风登记册。在接受初级保健调查的医生中,据报告40岁以上患者中接受血压筛查的不到30%,而接受房颤筛查的更少;在11个国家中的10个国家,65岁以上患者中接受房颤筛查的不到20%。
尽管在管理非传染性疾病负担方面正在取得进展,但我们的研究结果揭示了中风一级预防方面仍有改进的机会。需要在战略规划、提高意识和疾病监测方面进一步发展,同时也需要研究初级保健中实施血压和房颤最佳实践筛查的障碍。