Christian Natalie, Kearns Katherine D
Evolution, Ecology and Behavior Program, Department of Biology, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405.
Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN 47405.
J Microbiol Biol Educ. 2018 Aug 31;19(2). doi: 10.1128/jmbe.v19i2.1564. eCollection 2018.
s play the pivotal role of selling an article to a prospective reader, and for students, the ability to communicate science in concise written form may foster scientific thinking. However, students struggle with abstract composition, and we lack evidence-based educational innovations to help them develop this skill. We designed, implemented, and assessed an intervention for abstract composition with elements of scaffolding and transparency to ask whether deliberate practice improves concise scientific writing in early career undergraduate biology majors. We evaluated student performance by analyzing abstracts written before and after the intervention and by assessing pre- and posttest student concept maps. We found that scaffolded learning improved student abstract writing, with the greatest gains in students' ability to describe the motivation for their work. Using a set of tested tools to teach scientific writing has important implications for strengthening students' capacity to reinforce and synthesize content in the future, whether that is in laboratory course exercises, in independent research, or as a transferable skill to general critical thinking.
摘要在向潜在读者推销一篇文章方面起着关键作用,对于学生而言,以简洁书面形式交流科学知识的能力可能会促进科学思维。然而,学生在撰写摘要时遇到困难,而且我们缺乏基于证据的教育创新方法来帮助他们培养这项技能。我们设计、实施并评估了一项针对摘要撰写的干预措施,该措施具有支架式教学和透明度的元素,以探究刻意练习是否能提高本科生物专业低年级学生简洁的科学写作能力。我们通过分析干预前后撰写的摘要以及评估学生的课前和课后概念图来评估学生的表现。我们发现支架式学习提高了学生的摘要写作能力,其中学生描述其研究动机的能力提升最为显著。使用一套经过测试的工具来教授科学写作对于增强学生未来强化和综合内容的能力具有重要意义,无论是在实验室课程练习中、独立研究中,还是作为一种可迁移到一般批判性思维的技能。