Leppilahti Jussi M, Harjunmaa Ulla, Järnstedt Jorma, Mangani Charles, Hernández Marcela, Tervahartiala Taina, Lopez Rodrigo, Ashorn Ulla, Ashorn Per, Gieselmann Dirk-Rolf, Sorsa Timo
Department of Periodontology and Geriatric Dentistry, University of Oulu, Oulu 90014, Finland.
Center for Child Health Research, University of Tampere, Tampere 33014, Finland.
Diagnostics (Basel). 2018 Sep 15;8(3):67. doi: 10.3390/diagnostics8030067.
A novel qualitative point-of-care test of activated matrix metalloproteinase-8 (aMMP-8) using noninvasive oral rinse sampling procedures has been developed for the early detection of collagen breakdown indicating periodontal tissue destruction. The main object of this study was to assess the reliability of the test in a low-income setting to identify participants with history of periodontal destruction detected as alveolar bone loss (ABL) in radiographs. This cross-sectional study included 486 women who had recently delivered in rural Malawi. The aMMP-8 test and dental panoramic radiographs were taken within 48 h of delivery. The performance of the test in comparison to radiological examinations was tested by following the standards for reporting of diagnostic accuracy studies protocol (STARD) with respective statistical measures and 95% confidence intervals. From the 486 eligible participants, 461 mothers with complete data, aged from 15 to 46 years (mean 24.8, SD 6.0) were included in the analysis. ABL was identified in 116 of 461 participants. There was 56% agreement between the aMMP-8 test results and detected ABL (yes or no) in radiographs. Calculated sensitivity of the test was 80% (72⁻87%), specificity 48% (43⁻54%), positive predictive value 34% (31⁻37%), negative predictive value 88% (83⁻91%), positive likelihood ratio 1.55 (1.35⁻1.77), and negative likelihood ratio 0.41(0.28⁻0.60). The aMMP-8 test sensitivity and negative predictive value to identify the ABL cases were relatively high, but there was additionally a high rate of test-positive results in participants without ABL, especially in young mothers, leading to low overall agreement between the test results and radiological bone loss. Further longitudinal studies are needed to examine if the test positive subjects are in risk of future bone loss before the detectable signs of periodontitis in radiographs.
一种使用非侵入性口腔冲洗采样程序对活化基质金属蛋白酶-8(aMMP-8)进行的新型即时检测方法已被开发出来,用于早期检测表明牙周组织破坏的胶原蛋白分解。本研究的主要目的是评估该检测方法在低收入环境中识别有牙周破坏病史(在X线片上表现为牙槽骨吸收[ABL])参与者的可靠性。这项横断面研究纳入了486名近期在马拉维农村地区分娩的妇女。在分娩后48小时内进行了aMMP-8检测和牙科全景X线片检查。按照诊断准确性研究报告标准协议(STARD)及相应的统计方法和95%置信区间,对该检测方法与放射学检查的性能进行了测试。在486名符合条件的参与者中,461名有完整数据、年龄在15至46岁(平均24.8岁,标准差6.0)的母亲被纳入分析。461名参与者中有116名被诊断为ABL。aMMP-8检测结果与X线片上检测到的ABL(是或否)之间的一致性为56%。该检测方法计算出的敏感性为80%(72⁻87%),特异性为48%(43⁻54%),阳性预测值为34%(31⁻37%),阴性预测值为88%(83⁻91%),阳性似然比为1.55(1.35⁻1.77),阴性似然比为0.41(0.28⁻0.60)。aMMP-8检测识别ABL病例的敏感性和阴性预测值相对较高,但在无ABL的参与者中检测结果呈阳性的比例也很高,尤其是年轻母亲,导致检测结果与放射学骨吸收之间的总体一致性较低。需要进一步进行纵向研究,以检查检测呈阳性的受试者在X线片上出现可检测到的牙周炎迹象之前是否有未来骨吸收的风险。