School of Geodesy and Geomatics, Wuhan University, Wuhan 430079, China.
State Key Laboratory of Earth Surface Processes and Resource Ecology, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China.
Sensors (Basel). 2018 Sep 18;18(9):3153. doi: 10.3390/s18093153.
Deep learning techniques have boosted the performance of hyperspectral image (HSI) classification. In particular, convolutional neural networks (CNNs) have shown superior performance to that of the conventional machine learning algorithms. Recently, a novel type of neural networks called capsule networks (CapsNets) was presented to improve the most advanced CNNs. In this paper, we present a modified two-layer CapsNet with limited training samples for HSI classification, which is inspired by the comparability and simplicity of the shallower deep learning models. The presented CapsNet is trained using two real HSI datasets, i.e., the PaviaU (PU) and SalinasA datasets, representing complex and simple datasets, respectively, and which are used to investigate the robustness or representation of every model or classifier. In addition, a comparable paradigm of network architecture design has been proposed for the comparison of CNN and CapsNet. Experiments demonstrate that CapsNet shows better accuracy and convergence behavior for the complex data than the state-of-the-art CNN. For CapsNet using the PU dataset, the Kappa coefficient, overall accuracy, and average accuracy are 0.9456, 95.90%, and 96.27%, respectively, compared to the corresponding values yielded by CNN of 0.9345, 95.11%, and 95.63%. Moreover, we observed that CapsNet has much higher confidence for the predicted probabilities. Subsequently, this finding was analyzed and discussed with probability maps and uncertainty analysis. In terms of the existing literature, CapsNet provides promising results and explicit merits in comparison with CNN and two baseline classifiers, i.e., random forests (RFs) and support vector machines (SVMs).
深度学习技术提高了高光谱图像 (HSI) 分类的性能。特别是,卷积神经网络 (CNN) 已经表现出优于传统机器学习算法的性能。最近,一种新型的神经网络被称为胶囊网络 (CapsNets),用于改进最先进的 CNN。在本文中,我们提出了一种具有有限训练样本的改进的两层胶囊网络,用于 HSI 分类,该网络的灵感来自于较浅的深度学习模型的可比性和简单性。所提出的胶囊网络使用两个真实的 HSI 数据集进行训练,即 PaviaU (PU) 和 SalinasA 数据集,分别代表复杂和简单的数据集,用于研究每个模型或分类器的鲁棒性或表示能力。此外,还提出了一种可比较的网络架构设计范例,用于比较 CNN 和 CapsNet。实验表明,CapsNet 对复杂数据的准确性和收敛行为优于最新的 CNN。对于使用 PU 数据集的 CapsNet,Kappa 系数、总体准确率和平均准确率分别为 0.9456、95.90%和 96.27%,而 CNN 的相应值分别为 0.9345、95.11%和 95.63%。此外,我们观察到 CapsNet 对预测概率的置信度要高得多。随后,通过概率图和不确定性分析对这一发现进行了分析和讨论。在现有文献中,与 CNN 和两个基线分类器(随机森林 (RF) 和支持向量机 (SVM))相比,CapsNet 提供了有前途的结果和明显的优势。