我们应该持续进行胃癌筛查多久?从流行病学角度来看。
How long should we continue gastric cancer screening? From an epidemiological point of view.
机构信息
Division of Health Sociology, Center for Public Health Sciences, National Cancer Center, 5-1-1 Tsukiji, Chuo, Tokyo, 104-0045, Japan.
出版信息
Gastric Cancer. 2019 May;22(3):456-462. doi: 10.1007/s10120-018-0877-z. Epub 2018 Sep 21.
BACKGROUND
In Japan, incidence of gastric cancer is expected to follow the current downward trend as the younger generation has lower incidence of Helicobacter pylori infection. In this study we aimed to estimate how long gastric cancer screening is deemed necessary in the future from epidemiologic perspectives.
METHODS
Following the Japanese guidelines for gastric cancer screening 2014, recommendation of providing population-based gastric cancer screening is judged by balancing benefits and harms. Benefits and harms are estimated by number needed to screen (NNS) < 1000 and Number Needed to Recall (NNR) < 100. NNS is the number of people required to participate in a screening to prevent one death and NNR is the number of people required to undergo diagnostic examination to prevent one death. These index are estimated for 2020-2035 using future projections of gastric cancer mortality for the scenarios of relative risk (RR) of 0.5-0.9 for mortality reduction by the screening.
RESULTS
The criteria of both NNS < 1000 and NNR < 100 are fulfilled for the following age groups: when RR is set as 0.6, men ≥ 55 and women ≥ 65; when RR is set as 0.7 and 0.8, men ≥ 65 and women ≥ 75; when RR is set as 0.9, men ≥ 75 only.
CONCLUSIONS
In case of RR of 0.5 and 0.6, the gastric cancer screening are recommended for men ≥ 55 and women ≥ 65 until 2035, while it is not recommended for men and women in the 45-54 even in 2010 and 2015.
背景
在日本,由于年轻一代幽门螺杆菌感染率较低,预计胃癌发病率将延续当前的下降趋势。本研究旨在从流行病学角度估算未来需要进行多长时间的胃癌筛查。
方法
根据 2014 年日本胃癌筛查指南,提供基于人群的胃癌筛查的建议是通过平衡获益和危害来判断的。受益和危害通过需要筛查的人数(NNS)<1000 和需要召回的人数(NNR)<100 来估计。NNS 是指预防 1 例死亡需要筛查的人数,NNR 是指预防 1 例死亡需要进行诊断检查的人数。使用 2020-2035 年胃癌死亡率的未来预测数据,对筛查降低死亡率的相对风险(RR)为 0.5-0.9 的情况下的 NNS 和 NNR 进行估计。
结果
RR 设定为 0.6 时,对于男性 ≥ 55 岁和女性 ≥ 65 岁,以及 RR 设定为 0.7 和 0.8 时,男性 ≥ 65 岁和女性 ≥ 75 岁,以及 RR 设定为 0.9 时,男性 ≥ 75 岁,这两个标准都符合 NNS<1000 和 NNR<100。
结论
RR 为 0.5 和 0.6 时,建议 2035 年前男性 ≥ 55 岁和女性 ≥ 65 岁进行胃癌筛查,而在 2010 年和 2015 年,45-54 岁的男性和女性则不建议进行筛查。