Dr. Jiang, Dr. Linlin Hu, Mr. Wu, Dr. Zhao, Dr. Guangyu Hu, and Dr. Yuanli Liu are with the Public Health School, and Dr. Wan is with the Institute of Basic Medical Sciences, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences, and School of Basic Medicine, Peking Union Medical College, Beijing. Dr. Rakofsky and Dr. Tang are with the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Emory University, Atlanta. Dr. Tang is also with the Atlanta Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Decatur, Georgia. Dr. Tingfang Liu is with the Institute for Hospital Management, Tsinghua University, Beijing. Dr. Huanzhong Liu is with the Department of Psychiatry, Chaohu Hospital, Anhui Medical University, Hefei, China.
Psychiatr Serv. 2018 Dec 1;69(12):1245-1251. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201800197. Epub 2018 Oct 10.
The aim of the study was to establish a comprehensive understanding of the sociodemographic characteristics of psychiatrists in China and their working environment and job satisfaction.
As part of a national survey, the authors conducted China's first survey in 32 tertiary psychiatric hospitals, including administration of a structured questionnaire for psychiatrists. Participants also completed the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire (MSQ).
Of 3,363 surveyed psychiatrists, 2,715 (81%) responded, and 2,602 (77%) completed the survey. Among completers, 58% were women, and 83% were ages 30-49. Significant differences were found in actual and expected monthly income between male and female psychiatrists and across various regions. The mean±SD MSQ score was 71.6±14.3, suggesting moderate job satisfaction. The top three reasons for dissatisfaction were low pay, contentious doctor-patient relationships, and a heavy workload. One-fifth (20%) of participants reported an intention to quit their jobs. MSQ score was significantly associated with younger age, shorter working hours, higher monthly pay, and a smaller gap between expected and actual pay. Being in an administrative position, having medical liability insurance, and not having experienced medical disputes appeared to have a positive impact on job satisfaction.
Compared with their international counterparts, psychiatrists in China have a low level of the job satisfaction, especially those in West China. Given China's increasing demand for psychiatric services, policy makers in China urgently need to find ways to improve the job satisfaction of working psychiatrists and should consider enhancements in financial compensation, the working environment, and malpractice insurance coverage.
本研究旨在全面了解中国精神科医生的社会人口学特征、工作环境和工作满意度。
作为全国性调查的一部分,作者对 32 家三级精神病院进行了首次调查,包括对精神科医生进行结构化问卷调查。参与者还完成了明尼苏达满意度问卷(MSQ)。
在接受调查的 3363 名精神科医生中,有 2715 名(81%)做出了回应,其中 2602 名(77%)完成了调查。在完成调查的人中,58%为女性,83%年龄在 30-49 岁之间。男女精神科医生之间以及不同地区之间的实际和预期月收入存在显著差异。MSQ 平均得分±SD 为 71.6±14.3,表明工作满意度中等。不满的前三个原因是薪酬低、医患关系紧张和工作量大。五分之一(20%)的参与者表示打算辞职。MSQ 评分与年龄较小、工作时间较短、月收入较高以及期望和实际薪酬差距较小显著相关。担任行政职务、拥有医疗责任保险以及没有经历过医疗纠纷似乎对工作满意度有积极影响。
与国际同行相比,中国精神科医生的工作满意度较低,特别是在中国西部。考虑到中国对精神科服务的需求不断增加,中国的政策制定者迫切需要找到提高在职精神科医生工作满意度的方法,应考虑增加经济补偿、改善工作环境和扩大医疗事故保险范围。