School of Public Health, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences & Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, P.R. China.
Hospital Management Institute, Fudan University, Shanghai, P.R. China.
PLoS One. 2018 Oct 11;13(10):e0205489. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0205489. eCollection 2018.
To develop a set of structure and process indicators to evaluate tertiary hospitals' performance in the Healthcare Improvement Initiative, a national program with a goal to improve quality of patient-centered care.
A modified Delphi technique, including literature review, multidisciplinary panel meeting and anonymous rating, was used to generate a set of indicators. A practice test involving both general and special hospitals was conducted to ensure the feasibility of data collection for these indicators.
62 indicators were generated by literature review. The panel review procedure involving 39 panelists with diverse backgrounds resulted in a total of 59 indicators, which included 40 qualitative indicators and 19 quantitative indicators. In the practice test, six quantitative indicators were found unfeasible. According to the suggestion of the experts in the hospital evaluation committee, three of those indicators were kept by adjusting their data collection methods, while other three ones were discarded.
A set of 56 structure and process indicators was developed to evaluate hospitals' performance in the implementation of the Healthcare Improvement Initiative, which could be used in both general and special tertiary hospitals. Results of the indicator measurement could present a panorama of the quality of patient-centered care in tertiary hospitals nation-wide, and inform health administrators of the ways to attain the goal of the Initiative.
开发一套结构和过程指标,以评估三级医院在医疗保健改进倡议中的绩效,该倡议是一个旨在提高以患者为中心的护理质量的国家级项目。
采用改良 Delphi 技术,包括文献回顾、多学科专家组会议和匿名评分,生成一套指标。进行了一项涉及综合医院和专科医院的实践测试,以确保这些指标数据收集的可行性。
文献回顾产生了 62 项指标。涉及背景多样的 39 名专家的小组审查程序产生了总共 59 项指标,其中包括 40 项定性指标和 19 项定量指标。在实践测试中,发现 6 项定量指标不可行。根据医院评估委员会专家的建议,其中 3 项指标通过调整数据收集方法保留,另外 3 项指标被丢弃。
开发了一套 56 项结构和过程指标,用于评估医院在实施医疗保健改进倡议方面的绩效,可用于综合和专科医院。指标测量的结果可以呈现全国三级医院以患者为中心的护理质量全景,并为卫生管理人员提供实现倡议目标的途径。