Orthopedic Department, University Hospital of Aalborg, Hobrovej 18-22, 9000, Aalborg, Denmark.
Arts et Metiers ParisTech, LBM/Institut de Biomecanique Humaine Georges Charpak, 151 bd de l'Hopital, 75013, Paris, France.
Eur Radiol. 2019 Apr;29(4):1874-1881. doi: 10.1007/s00330-018-5749-8. Epub 2018 Oct 22.
The aim of this study was to validate the reproducibility of 3D reconstructions of the spine using a new reduced micro-dose protocol.
First, semi-quantitative image analysis was performed using an anthropomorphic child phantom undergoing low-dose biplanar radiography. This analysis was used to establish a "lowest dose" allowing for acceptable visibility of spinal landmarks. Subsequently, a group of 18 scoliotic children, 12 years of age or younger, underwent full-spine biplanar radiography with both micro-dose and the newly defined reduced micro-dose. An intra- and inter-observer reliability study of 3D reconstructions of the spine was performed according to the International Organization for Standardization (ISO)-5725 standard, with three operators.
The reduced micro-dose setting corresponded to a theoretical reduction of radiation dose exposure of approximately 58%. In vivo results showed acceptable intra- and inter-observer reliability (for instance, 3.8° uncertainty on Cobb angle), comparable to previous studies on 3D spine reconstruction reliability and reproducibility based on stereo-radiography.
A new reduced micro-dose protocol offered reliable 3D reconstructions of the spine in patients with mild scoliosis. However, the quality of 3D reconstructions from both reduced micro-dose and micro-dose was inferior to standard-dose protocol on most parameters. Standard-dose protocol remains the option of choice for most accurate assessment and 3D reconstruction of the spine. Still, this new protocol offers a preliminary screening option and a follow-up tool for children with mild scoliosis yielding extremely low radiation and could replace micro-dose protocol for these patients.
• We investigated the reliability of 3D reconstructions of the spine based on a new stereo-radiography protocol reducing radiation dose by 58% compared with established micro-dose imaging protocol. • The new reduced micro-dose protocol offers a reproducible preliminary screening option and a follow-up tool in the necessarily frequent repeat imaging of children with mild scoliosis yielding extremely low radiation and could replace existing micro-dose protocol for these patients. • EOS standard-dose protocol remains the option of choice for exact radiographic assessment of scoliosis, offering more exact 3D reproducibility of the spine compared to both micro-dose and the new reduced micro-dose protocols.
本研究旨在验证一种新的微剂量缩减方案在脊柱 3D 重建中的可重复性。
首先,对接受低剂量双平面放射摄影的人体模型进行半定量图像分析。该分析用于确定允许脊柱标志可见的“最低剂量”。随后,对 18 名年龄在 12 岁以下的脊柱侧弯儿童进行全脊柱双平面微剂量和新定义的微剂量缩减摄影。根据国际标准化组织(ISO)-5725 标准,由三位操作人员对脊柱 3D 重建进行了内部和外部观察者可靠性研究。
微剂量缩减设置相当于理论辐射剂量暴露的约 58%减少。体内结果显示,具有可接受的内部和外部观察者可靠性(例如,Cobb 角的 3.8°不确定性),与之前基于立体放射摄影的脊柱 3D 重建可靠性和可重复性研究相当。
新的微剂量缩减方案为轻度脊柱侧弯患者提供了可靠的脊柱 3D 重建。然而,在大多数参数上,微剂量和微剂量缩减的 3D 重建质量都劣于标准剂量方案。对于大多数脊柱的准确评估和 3D 重建,标准剂量方案仍然是首选方案。尽管如此,该新方案仍为轻度脊柱侧弯患者提供了一种初步筛查选择和随访工具,其辐射极低,可替代这些患者的微剂量方案。
我们研究了基于与现有微剂量成像方案相比减少 58%辐射剂量的新立体放射摄影方案的脊柱 3D 重建的可靠性。
新的微剂量缩减方案为轻度脊柱侧弯患者提供了一种可重复的初步筛查选择和随访工具,在儿童频繁重复成像时具有极低的辐射量,并可替代这些患者的现有微剂量方案。
EOS 标准剂量方案仍然是脊柱侧弯精确放射评估的选择方案,与微剂量和新的微剂量缩减方案相比,提供了更精确的脊柱 3D 可重复性。