Jaeb Center for Health Research, Tampa, FL
International Diabetes Center Park Nicollet, Minneapolis, MN.
Diabetes Care. 2019 Mar;42(3):400-405. doi: 10.2337/dc18-1444. Epub 2018 Oct 23.
This study evaluated the association of time in range (TIR) of 70-180 mg/dL (3.9-10 mmol/L) with the development or progression of retinopathy and development of microalbuminuria using the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial (DCCT) data set in order to validate the use of TIR as an outcome measure for clinical trials.
In the DCCT, blood glucose concentrations were measured at a central laboratory from seven fingerstick samples (seven-point testing: pre- and 90-min postmeals and at bedtime) collected during 1 day every 3 months. Retinopathy progression was assessed every 6 months and urinary microalbuminuria development every 12 months. Proportional hazards models were used to assess the association of TIR and other glycemic metrics, computed from the seven-point fingerstick data, with the rate of development of microvascular complications.
Mean TIR of seven-point profiles for the 1,440 participants was 41 ± 16%. The hazard rate of development of retinopathy progression was increased by 64% (95% CI 51-78), and development of the microalbuminuria outcome was increased by 40% (95% CI 25-56), for each 10 percentage points lower TIR ( < 0.001 for each). Results were similar for mean glucose and hyperglycemia metrics.
Based on these results, a compelling case can be made that TIR is strongly associated with the risk of microvascular complications and should be an acceptable end point for clinical trials. Although hemoglobin A remains a valuable outcome metric in clinical trials, TIR and other glycemic metrics-especially when measured with continuous glucose monitoring-add value as outcome measures in many studies.
本研究使用糖尿病控制与并发症试验(DCCT)数据集评估 70-180mg/dL(3.9-10mmol/L)范围内时间(TIR)与视网膜病变发展或进展以及微量白蛋白尿发展的相关性,以验证 TIR 作为临床试验结果衡量指标的适用性。
在 DCCT 中,每 3 个月采集 1 天内的 7 个指尖样本(七点检测:餐前和 90 分钟餐后以及睡前),由中心实验室测量血糖浓度。每 6 个月评估视网膜病变进展情况,每 12 个月评估尿微量白蛋白尿进展情况。采用比例风险模型评估 TIR 与其他从七点指尖数据计算得出的血糖指标与微血管并发症发展速度的相关性。
1440 名参与者的七点血糖 TIR 平均值为 41±16%。TIR 每降低 10 个百分点,视网膜病变进展的发生风险增加 64%(95%CI 51-78),微量白蛋白尿结局的发生风险增加 40%(95%CI 25-56)(均<0.001)。平均血糖和高血糖指标的结果类似。
基于这些结果,可以强有力地证明 TIR 与微血管并发症风险密切相关,应该成为临床试验的可接受终点。尽管血红蛋白 A 仍然是临床试验中有价值的结果衡量指标,但 TIR 和其他血糖指标——尤其是当使用连续血糖监测测量时——作为许多研究的结果衡量指标具有附加价值。