School of Public Health, Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas, USA.
Center of Applied Health Research, Baylor Scott and White Health, Temple, Texas, USA.
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2018 Dec 1;25(12):1675-1684. doi: 10.1093/jamia/ocy128.
To conduct a systematic review of instruments used in national surveys of eHealth behaviors.
Major databases and websites of federal agencies were searched with pre-determined inclusion and exclusion criteria. National surveys with measures of eHealth behaviors were identified. The survey instruments were retrieved, and their measures of eHealth behaviors were categorized and critiqued.
We located 13 national surveys containing eHealth behavior assessment questions that were administered from 1999 to 2017. Most surveys were conducted annually or biennially and typically covered topics on searching health information, obtaining social support, communicating with healthcare providers, and buying medicine online; recent surveys included items related to personal health management and use of mobile tools. There were redundant measures of searching health information online but insufficient measures of use of mobile apps, social media, and wearable devices.
Future assessment of eHealth behaviors should reflect the growing varieties of behaviors enabled by technology development and reflect the current mobile ownership patterns in diverse social groups. More studies also need to include longitudinal surveys, integrative and standardized measures, and better designs to allow data linkage and comparison.
The existing survey instruments covering eHealth behaviors are rather limited compared to fast technological progress. We call for more national surveys on eHealth behaviors that are more responsive to technology development; we also advocate for more analysis and dissemination of existing national data on eHealth behaviors for evidence-based health policies.
对用于电子健康行为的国家调查的工具进行系统评价。
根据预先确定的纳入和排除标准,在主要数据库和联邦机构网站上进行了检索。确定了包含电子健康行为测量的国家调查。检索调查工具,并对电子健康行为的测量方法进行分类和评价。
我们找到了 13 项包含电子健康行为评估问题的国家调查,这些调查于 1999 年至 2017 年进行。大多数调查每年或每两年进行一次,通常涵盖搜索健康信息、获得社会支持、与医疗保健提供者沟通和在线购买药品等主题;最近的调查包括与个人健康管理和使用移动工具相关的项目。有许多重复的在线搜索健康信息的措施,但对移动应用程序、社交媒体和可穿戴设备的使用的测量措施不足。
未来对电子健康行为的评估应反映技术发展带来的各种行为变化,并反映不同社会群体中当前的移动设备拥有模式。还需要更多的研究包括纵向调查、综合和标准化的措施以及更好的设计,以允许数据链接和比较。
与快速的技术进步相比,现有的涵盖电子健康行为的调查工具相当有限。我们呼吁进行更多响应技术发展的电子健康行为的国家调查;我们还主张对电子健康行为的现有国家数据进行更多的分析和传播,以制定基于证据的健康政策。