Ghosh Debabrata, Brar Harmeet, Lhamu Ugen, Rothner A David, Erenberg Gerald
Departments of Neurology and Pediatrics Nationwide Children's Hospital Ohio State University Medical Center Columbus Ohio USA.
Pediatric Neurology Center Children's Hospital Cleveland Clinic Cleveland Ohio USA.
Mov Disord Clin Pract. 2016 Jul 8;4(2):231-236. doi: 10.1002/mdc3.12385. eCollection 2017 Mar-Apr.
The objective of this study was to characterize the clinical features, course, and treatment of essential tremor (ET) in children.
A retrospective chart review was conducted over 25 years (1984-2011). Inclusion criteria were age <21 years and satisfying the core diagnostic criteria for ET. Primary exclusion criteria included other neurological findings, tremorogenic medications, sudden onset/stepwise progression, primary orthostatic tremor, and isolated task specificity; and secondary exclusion criteria were abnormal neuroimaging or metabolic/thyroid studies. Cases were reviewed for age, sex, family history, tremor characteristics, functional impairment, treatment, and follow-up.
In total, 211 children had ET, including 130 males and 81 females. The mean ± standard deviation age was at diagnosis was 14.09 ± 5.0 years, the age of onset was 9.71 ± 5.62 years, and the age of onset was birth in 7 children. One hundred ninety-nine children had bilateral hand tremor, 34 had asymmetry, 9 had unilateral onset but later became bilateral. Twelve children had voice tremors, 13 had leg tremors, 5 had head tremors, and 7 had trunk tremors. Tremor at rest was present in 20 children. Thirty-five percent of the children had a family history of ET, including in a father (n = 21), mother (n = 13), brother (n = 6), sister (n = 3), and other family member (n = 28). Fifty-five percent of patients had functional disabilities, including writing (n = 66), eating (n = 28) drinking from a cup (n = 13), typing (n = 4), playing instruments (n = 6), buttoning (n = 6), and playing (n = 3). For treatment, 33 patients received propranolol, 1 received atenolol, 13 received primidone, 3 received metoprolol, and 1 received nadolol. In total, 99 patients were followed for a mean ± standard deviation of 1.82 ± 2.21 years.If left untreated, tremor remained unchanged in 33 patients, and 7 had an apparent short-term improvement. On propranolol, 15 of 20 patients significantly improved.
This is the largest series to date of ET in children. The current findings indicate that onset at birth is possible, family history is less common in children than in adults, and tremor at rest is possible. Functional disability was noted in 55% of children, and 29.4% required medication.
本研究的目的是描述儿童特发性震颤(ET)的临床特征、病程及治疗情况。
进行了一项为期25年(1984 - 2011年)的回顾性病历审查。纳入标准为年龄<21岁且符合ET的核心诊断标准。主要排除标准包括其他神经系统表现、致震颤药物、突然起病/阶梯式进展、原发性直立性震颤及孤立的任务特异性震颤;次要排除标准为神经影像学异常或代谢/甲状腺检查异常。对病例进行年龄、性别、家族史、震颤特征、功能障碍、治疗及随访情况的审查。
共有211例儿童患有ET,其中男性130例,女性81例。诊断时的平均±标准差年龄为14.09±5.0岁,起病年龄为9.71±5.62岁,7例患儿起病于出生时。199例儿童有双侧手部震颤,34例有不对称性震颤,9例单侧起病但后来变为双侧。12例儿童有语音震颤,13例有腿部震颤,5例有头部震颤,7例有躯干震颤。20例儿童存在静止性震颤。35%的儿童有ET家族史,包括父亲(n = 21)、母亲(n = 13)、兄弟(n = 6)、姐妹(n = 3)及其他家庭成员(n = 28)。55%的患者有功能障碍,包括书写(n = 66)、进食(n = 28)、用杯子饮水(n = 13)、打字(n = 4)、演奏乐器(n = 6)、扣纽扣(n = 6)及玩耍(n = 3)。治疗方面,33例患者接受普萘洛尔治疗,1例接受阿替洛尔治疗,13例接受扑米酮治疗,3例接受美托洛尔治疗,1例接受纳多洛尔治疗。共有99例患者接受随访,平均±标准差为1.82±2.21年。若不治疗,33例患者震颤无变化,7例有明显短期改善。接受普萘洛尔治疗的20例患者中,15例有显著改善。
这是迄今为止关于儿童ET的最大系列研究。目前的研究结果表明,出生时起病是可能的,儿童家族史比成人少见,静止性震颤是可能的。55%的儿童有功能障碍,29.4%需要药物治疗。