Tseng Chu-Yao, Huang Ching-Wen, Huang Hsin-Chia, Tseng Wei-Chen
Division of Chinese Acupuncture and Traumatology, Center of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Taoyuan, Taiwan.
Chang Gung University College of Medicine, Taoyuan, Taiwan.
Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2018 Sep 30;2018:1706517. doi: 10.1155/2018/1706517. eCollection 2018.
Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) divides fracture treatment into three stages. Many TCM herbs and formulas have been used to treat fractures for thousands of years. However, research regarding the Chinese herbal products (CHPs) that should be used at different periods of treatment is still lacking. This study aims to identify the CHPs that should be used at different periods of treatment as well as confirm the TCM theory of fracture periods medicine. We used prescriptions of TCM outpatients with fracture diagnoses analyzed using the Chang Gung Research Database (CGRD) from 2000 to 2015. According to the number of days between the date of the fracture and the clinic visit date, all patients were assigned to one of three groups. Patients with a date gap of 0-13 days were assigned to the early period group; those with a date gap of 14-82 days were assigned to the middle period group; and those with a date gap of 83-182 days were assigned to the late period group. We observed the average number of herbal formulas prescribed by the TCM doctor at each visit was 2.78, and the average number of single herbs prescribed was 6.47. The top three prescriptions in the early fracture period were Zheng-gu-zi-jin-dang, Shu-jing-huo-xue-tang, and Wu-ling-san. In the middle fracture period, the top three formulas were Zheng-gu-zi-jin-dang, Shu-jing-huo-xue-tang, and Zhi-bai-di-huang-wan. In the late fracture period, the top three formulas were Shu-jing-huo-xue-tang, Gui-lu-er-xian-jiao, and Du-huo-ji-sheng-tang. The main single herbs used in the early fracture period were Yan-hu-suo, Gu-sui-bu, and Dan-shen. From the middle to the late period, the most prescribed single herbs were Xu-duan, Gu-sui-bu, and Yan-hu-suo. We concluded that the results showed that the CGRD utilization pattern roughly meets the TCM theory at different fracture periods.
中医将骨折治疗分为三个阶段。数千年来,许多中药和方剂一直被用于治疗骨折。然而,关于在治疗不同阶段应使用的中药产品(CHPs)的研究仍然缺乏。本研究旨在确定在治疗不同阶段应使用的CHPs,并证实骨折分期用药的中医理论。我们使用了长庚研究数据库(CGRD)中2000年至2015年诊断为骨折的中医门诊患者的处方。根据骨折日期与门诊就诊日期之间的天数,将所有患者分为三组。骨折日期与就诊日期间隔为0至13天的患者被分配到早期组;间隔为14至82天的患者被分配到中期组;间隔为83至182天的患者被分配到晚期组。我们观察到,中医医生每次就诊开出的中药方剂平均数量为2.78,单味中药平均数量为6.47。骨折早期的前三种方剂为正骨紫金丹、舒筋活血汤和五苓散。骨折中期,前三种方剂为正骨紫金丹、舒筋活血汤和知柏地黄丸。骨折晚期,前三种方剂为舒筋活血汤、龟鹿二仙胶和独活寄生汤。骨折早期使用的主要单味中药为延胡索、骨碎补和丹参。从中期到晚期,使用最多的单味中药为续断、骨碎补和延胡索。我们得出结论,结果表明CGRD的使用模式大致符合不同骨折阶段的中医理论。