Yoshida Yukihiro, Watanabe Shunichi
Dept. of Thoracic Surgery, National Cancer Center Hospital.
Gan To Kagaku Ryoho. 2018 Oct;45(10):1405-1409.
We have summarized the current role of surgery for primary lung cancer based on solid evidence from clinical trials. Notably, LCSG 821 is the sole clinical trial that has compared lobectomy with limited resection for early stage non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). This study demonstrated that limited resection led to a three-fold increase in locoregional recurrence and a 30% increase in mortality. Lobectomy has been the standard procedure based on the results of this single study, which was conducted in 1980's. Four clinical trials compared mediastinal lymph node dissection with sampling; however, all except 1 failed to demonstrate the survival benefit to lymph node dissection. The role of mediastinal lymph node dissection should be a more precise staging of mediastinal lymph node metastases. The role of surgery for NSCLC with mediastinal lymph node metastasis (ie, stage III A/N2)has not been proven in clinical trials. Because of the heterogeneity of patients with stage III A/N2 NSCLC, current guidelines recommend a multi-disciplinary discussion for each case. Superior sulcus tumor, which invades the chest wall, including the first rib, is a challenging operation for surgeons. Two phase II studies(in the United States and Japan) demonstrated that induction chemoradiotherapy followed by surgery offered promising results, with an approximately 70% complete resection rate and a 50%survival rate at 5 years. Video-assisted thoracic surgery(VATS)was evaluated in a multiinstitutional phase II study, which concluded that this approach is feasible for early stage NSCLC. However, significant evidence was accumulated based on retrospective cohort studies, and VATS lobectomy has become popular in daily practice.
我们基于临床试验的可靠证据总结了手术在原发性肺癌治疗中的当前作用。值得注意的是,肺癌研究组(LCSG)821是唯一一项比较早期非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)肺叶切除术与有限切除的临床试验。该研究表明,有限切除导致局部区域复发增加了两倍,死亡率增加了30%。基于这项在20世纪80年代进行的单一研究结果,肺叶切除术一直是标准术式。四项临床试验比较了纵隔淋巴结清扫与采样;然而,除1项外,所有试验均未能证明淋巴结清扫对生存有益。纵隔淋巴结清扫的作用应该是更精确地分期纵隔淋巴结转移。手术在伴有纵隔淋巴结转移的NSCLC(即ⅢA/N2期)中的作用在临床试验中尚未得到证实。由于ⅢA/N2期NSCLC患者的异质性,当前指南建议对每个病例进行多学科讨论。侵犯胸壁(包括第一肋骨)的肺上沟瘤对外科医生来说是一项具有挑战性的手术。两项Ⅱ期研究(在美国和日本)表明,诱导放化疗后手术取得了有希望的结果,完全切除率约为70%,5年生存率为50%。在一项多机构Ⅱ期研究中对电视辅助胸腔镜手术(VATS)进行了评估,该研究得出结论,这种方法对早期NSCLC是可行的。然而,基于回顾性队列研究积累了大量证据,VATS肺叶切除术在日常实践中已变得很普遍。