Northern Medial Program, University of Northern British Columbia, Prince George, Canada.
Department of Laboratory Medicine, Royal Jubilee Hospital, Victoria, Canada.
Anat Sci Educ. 2019 Nov;12(6):678-685. doi: 10.1002/ase.1844. Epub 2018 Dec 6.
Many technological innovations have changed the traditional practice of medical education and clinical practice. Whole slide imaging (WSI) technology provided an unique way of viewing conventional glass slides in histology and pathology laboratories. The WSI technology digitalized glass slide images and made them readily accessible via the Internet using tablets or computers. Users utilized the pan-and-zoom function to view digital images of slides, also referred to as the virtual microscope (VM), simulating use of an optical microscope (OM). Several articles have reported various outcomes on the utility of VM in teaching laboratories. Recently, the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada certification examinations for anatomical pathologists ha completely adopted VM for the national licensing examination. To better inform medical educators, there is an urgent need for more structured reviews to draw evidence-based conclusions on the effectiveness of VM and learner's perceptions, in comparison to OM. The current study provides a descriptive summary of published outcomes using the systematic review approach. In conclusion, medical students' performance was improved with adoption of VM into the curriculum and recognized as a preferred learning modality, compared to OM. On the contrary, resident learners' performance was comparable between using OM and VM, with OM being the favored slide-viewing modality.
许多技术创新改变了医学教育和临床实践的传统模式。全玻片成像(WSI)技术为组织学和病理学实验室中查看传统玻璃载玻片提供了一种独特的方式。WSI 技术将玻片图像数字化,并通过平板电脑或计算机通过互联网实现了便捷访问。用户利用平移和缩放功能查看玻片的数字图像,也称为虚拟显微镜(VM),模拟使用光学显微镜(OM)。有几篇文章报道了 VM 在教学实验室中的各种应用结果。最近,加拿大皇家内科和外科医师学院的解剖病理学家认证考试完全采用了 VM 作为全国许可考试。为了更好地为医学教育工作者提供信息,迫切需要更具结构性的审查,以在 VM 和学习者感知方面得出基于证据的结论,与 OM 进行比较。本研究使用系统综述方法对已发表的结果进行了描述性总结。总之,与 OM 相比,将 VM 纳入课程可提高医学生的表现,并被认为是一种更受欢迎的学习方式。相反,在使用 OM 和 VM 时,住院医师的学习表现相当,OM 是更受欢迎的玻片观察方式。