Yamasaki Brianna L, Luk Gigi
Department of Psychology, University of Washington, Seattle.
Harvard Graduate School of Education, Cambridge, MA.
Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 2018 Oct 24;49(4):889-901. doi: 10.1044/2018_LSHSS-DYSLC-18-0006.
We examined the association between language experience and elementary students' eligibility for special education in Massachusetts.
A secondary descriptive data analysis was conducted on the anonymized demographic data obtained from the Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. Third, 4th, and 5th grade students were categorized into native English speakers, English-proficient bilinguals, and emerging bilinguals. Eligibility for free or reduced lunch was also considered. Proportions of students eligible for autism, communication disorders, and specific learning disabilities (including those with dyslexia) were calculated.
A strong association was observed between students' language background and whether they were eligible for free/reduced lunch. Children eligible for free/reduced lunch were more likely to be eligible for special education. Relative to native English speakers, English-proficient bilingual students were less likely to be considered eligible for special education. However, for emerging bilinguals, eligibility was lowest in 3rd grade and highest in 5th grade. This observation was most apparent in the category of specific learning disabilities.
Students from diverse language and low-income backgrounds were disproportionately represented in special education. More substantial research-practice partnerships are warranted to understand how bilingual experience and socioeconomic status interact with eligibility for special education services in public school settings.
我们研究了语言经历与马萨诸塞州小学生接受特殊教育资格之间的关联。
对从马萨诸塞州小学和中学教育部门获取的匿名人口统计数据进行二次描述性数据分析。将三、四、五年级学生分为以英语为母语者、精通英语的双语者和新兴双语者。还考虑了获得免费或减价午餐的资格。计算了符合自闭症、沟通障碍和特定学习障碍(包括诵读困难症患者)资格的学生比例。
观察到学生的语言背景与他们是否有资格获得免费/减价午餐之间存在密切关联。符合免费/减价午餐资格的儿童更有可能符合特殊教育资格。相对于以英语为母语者,精通英语的双语学生被认为符合特殊教育资格的可能性较小。然而,对于新兴双语者,资格在三年级时最低,在五年级时最高。这一观察结果在特定学习障碍类别中最为明显。
来自不同语言和低收入背景的学生在特殊教育中的占比过高。需要建立更实质性的研究与实践伙伴关系,以了解双语经历和社会经济地位如何与公立学校环境中特殊教育服务的资格相互作用。