Health Products and Food Branch, Health Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Sanofi-Aventis SA, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA.
Clin Pharmacol Ther. 2019 Apr;105(4):844-856. doi: 10.1002/cpt.1317. Epub 2019 Jan 4.
Therapeutic product development, licensing and reimbursement may seem a well-oiled machine, but continuing high attrition rates, regulatory refusals, and patients' access issues suggest otherwise; despite serious efforts, gaps persist between stakeholders' stated evidence requirements and actual evidence supplied. Evidentiary deficiencies and/or human tendencies resulting in avoidable inefficiencies might be further reduced with fresh institutional cultures/mindsets, combined with a context-adaptable practices framework that integrates emerging innovations. Here, Structured Evidence Planning, Production, and Evaluation (SEPPE) posits that evidence be treated as something produced, much like other manufactured goods, for which "built-in quality" (i.e., "people" and "process") approaches have been successfully implemented globally. Incorporating proactive, iterative feedback-and-adjust loops involving key decision-makers at critical points could curtail avoidable evidence quality and decision hazards-pulling needed therapeutic products with high quality evidence of beneficial performance through to approvals. Critical for success, however, is dedicated, long-term commitment to systemic transformation.
治疗产品的开发、许可和报销看似运作良好,但持续高淘汰率、监管部门否决以及患者准入问题表明事实并非如此;尽管付出了巨大努力,但利益相关者所陈述的证据要求与实际提供的证据之间仍然存在差距。证据不足和/或人为的失误导致的不必要的低效率可能会随着新的机构文化/思维模式以及结合了新兴创新的适应性强的实践框架进一步减少。在这里,结构证据规划、制作和评估 (SEPPE) 假设证据应该被视为一种生产出来的东西,就像其他制成品一样,全球已经成功实施了“内在质量”(即“人员”和“流程”)方法。在关键决策点纳入涉及关键决策者的主动、迭代反馈和调整循环,可以避免不必要的证据质量和决策风险,从而通过高质量的疗效证据批准有前景的治疗产品。然而,成功的关键是对系统变革的长期承诺。