Weller David, Menon Usha, Zalounina Falborg Alina, Jensen Henry, Barisic Andriana, Knudsen Anne Kari, Bergin Rebecca J, Brewster David H, Cairnduff Victoria, Gavin Anna T, Grunfeld Eva, Harland Elizabeth, Lambe Mats, Law Rebecca-Jane, Lin Yulan, Malmberg Martin, Turner Donna, Neal Richard D, White Victoria, Harrison Samantha, Reguilon Irene, Vedsted Peter
MRC Clinical Trials Unit and Instittue of Clinical Trials and Methodology, University College London, London, UK.
Research Unit for General Practice, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark.
BMJ Open. 2018 Nov 27;8(11):e023870. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-023870.
International differences in colorectal cancer (CRC) survival and stage at diagnosis have been reported previously. They may be linked to differences in time intervals and routes to diagnosis. The International Cancer Benchmarking Partnership Module 4 (ICBP M4) reports the first international comparison of routes to diagnosis for patients with CRC and the time intervals from symptom onset until the start of treatment. Data came from patients in 10 jurisdictions across six countries (Canada, the UK, Norway, Sweden, Denmark and Australia).
Patients with CRC were identified via cancer registries. Data on symptomatic and screened patients were collected; questionnaire data from patients' primary care physicians and specialists, as well as information from treatment records or databases, supplemented patient data from the questionnaires. Routes to diagnosis and the key time intervals were described, as were between-jurisdiction differences in time intervals, using quantile regression.
A total of 14 664 eligible patients with CRC diagnosed between 2013 and 2015 were identified, of which 2866 were included in the analyses.
Interval lengths in days (primary), reported patient symptoms (secondary).
The main route to diagnosis for patients was symptomatic presentation and the most commonly reported symptom was 'bleeding/blood in stool'. The median intervals between jurisdictions ranged from: 21 to 49 days (patient); 0 to 12 days (primary care); 27 to 76 days (diagnostic); and 77 to 168 days (total, from first symptom to treatment start). Including screen-detected cases did not significantly alter the overall results.
ICBP M4 demonstrates important differences in time intervals between 10 jurisdictions internationally. The differences may justify efforts to reduce intervals in some jurisdictions.
先前已有关于结直肠癌(CRC)生存率及诊断时分期的国际差异报道。这些差异可能与诊断时间间隔及诊断途径的不同有关。国际癌症基准伙伴关系模块4(ICBP M4)报告了CRC患者诊断途径的首次国际比较以及从症状出现到治疗开始的时间间隔。数据来自六个国家(加拿大、英国、挪威、瑞典、丹麦和澳大利亚)的10个司法管辖区的患者。
通过癌症登记处识别CRC患者。收集有症状和筛查患者的数据;来自患者初级保健医生和专科医生的问卷数据,以及治疗记录或数据库中的信息,补充了问卷中的患者数据。描述了诊断途径和关键时间间隔,以及使用分位数回归分析的司法管辖区之间时间间隔的差异。
共识别出2013年至2015年期间诊断的14664例符合条件的CRC患者,其中2866例纳入分析。
以天数表示的时间间隔(主要指标),报告的患者症状(次要指标)。
患者的主要诊断途径是有症状表现,最常报告的症状是“便血/大便带血”。各司法管辖区之间的中位时间间隔为:21至49天(患者);0至12天(初级保健);27至76天(诊断);77至168天(总计,从首次症状到治疗开始)。纳入筛查发现的病例并未显著改变总体结果。
ICBP M4显示了国际上10个司法管辖区之间在时间间隔上的重要差异。这些差异可能证明在某些司法管辖区努力缩短时间间隔是合理的。