Department of Population & Quantitative Health Sciences, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, United States of America.
Department of Clinical Sciences, University of Louisiana at Monroe College of Pharmacy, Monroe, Louisiana, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2018 Nov 29;13(11):e0208047. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0208047. eCollection 2018.
Lack of consensus regarding the semantics and definitions of pediatric polypharmacy challenges researchers and clinicians alike. We conducted a scoping review to describe definitions and terminology of pediatric polypharmacy.
Medline, PubMed, EMBASE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Cochrane CENTRAL, and the Web of Science Core Collection databases were searched for English language articles with the concepts of "polypharmacy" and "children". Data were extracted about study characteristics, polypharmacy terms and definitions from qualifying studies, and were synthesized by disease conditions.
Out of 4,398 titles, we included 363 studies: 324 (89%) provided numeric definitions, 131 (36%) specified duration of polypharmacy, and 162 (45%) explicitly defined it. Over 81% (n = 295) of the studies defined polypharmacy as two or more medications or therapeutic classes. The most common comprehensive definitions of pediatric polypharmacy included: two or more concurrent medications for ≥1 day (n = 41), two or more concurrent medications for ≥31 days (n = 15), and two or more sequential medications over one year (n = 12). Commonly used terms included polypharmacy, polytherapy, combination pharmacotherapy, average number, and concomitant medications. The term polypharmacy was more common in psychiatry literature while epilepsy literature favored the term polytherapy.
Two or more concurrent medications, without duration, for ≥1 day, ≥31 days, or sequentially for one year were the most common definitions of pediatric polypharmacy. We recommend that pediatric polypharmacy studies specify the number of medications or therapeutic classes, if they are concurrent or sequential, and the duration of medications. We propose defining pediatric polypharmacy as "the prescription or consumption of two or more distinct medications for at least one day". The term "polypharmacy" should be included among key words and definitions in manuscripts.
儿科药物治疗学缺乏语义和定义共识,这给研究人员和临床医生都带来了挑战。我们进行了范围界定综述,旨在描述儿科药物治疗学的定义和术语。
检索 Medline、PubMed、EMBASE、CINAHL、PsycINFO、Cochrane CENTRAL 和 Web of Science 核心合集数据库,检索包含“药物治疗学”和“儿童”这两个概念的英文文章。从合格研究中提取关于研究特征、药物治疗学术语和定义的资料,并按疾病状况进行综合。
在 4398 个标题中,我们纳入了 363 项研究:324 项(89%)提供了数值定义,131 项(36%)规定了药物治疗学持续时间,162 项(45%)明确定义了药物治疗学。超过 81%(n=295)的研究将药物治疗学定义为两种或更多种药物或治疗类别。儿科药物治疗学最常见的综合定义包括:两种或更多种同时使用的药物持续≥1 天(n=41),两种或更多种同时使用的药物持续≥31 天(n=15),以及一种药物持续一年以上的两种或更多种序贯药物(n=12)。常用术语包括药物治疗学、多疗法、联合药物治疗学、平均数量和同时使用的药物。“药物治疗学”一词在精神病学文献中更为常见,而癫痫文献则倾向于使用“多疗法”一词。
两种或更多种同时使用的药物、没有持续时间、持续≥1 天、≥31 天或持续一年以上,这些是儿科药物治疗学最常见的定义。我们建议儿科药物治疗学研究明确药物或治疗类别的数量,如果是同时使用还是序贯使用,以及药物的持续时间。我们建议将儿科药物治疗学定义为“至少使用一种药物持续一天以上的两种或两种以上不同药物的处方或使用”。“药物治疗学”一词应列入手稿的关键词和定义中。