Roberts R, Braunwald E, Muller J E, Croft C, Gold H K, Hartwell T D, Jaffe A S, Mullin S M, Parker C, Passamani E R
Section of Cardiology, Baylor College of Medicine, Methodist Hospital, Houston, Texas 77030.
Br Heart J. 1988 Oct;60(4):290-8. doi: 10.1136/hrt.60.4.290.
A multicentred, randomised, blind study was started in 1978 to compare propranolol or hyaluronidase with placebo in patients with acute myocardial infarction admitted within 18 hours of onset of symptoms. Patients were randomised to group A and received hyaluronidase, propranolol, or placebo, or, if propranolol was contraindicated, to group B and received hyaluronidase or placebo. Hyaluronidase (500 U/kg given every six hours for 48 hours) had no effect on mortality or infarct size in the overall population. Because spontaneous reperfusion was more common in patients with early peaking of plasma creatine kinase MB or non-transmural electrocardiographic changes or both, the results were reanalysed for two subgroups: those in whom plasma creatine kinase peaked less than 15 hours after the onset of symptoms (early peak, n = 184) and those with a peak greater than 15 h after the onset of symptoms (late peak, n = 546). The distribution of time to peak activity of creatine kinase MB was similar in the hyaluronidase and placebo groups. In the early peak patients who were given hyaluronidase (groups A and B) total mortality and cardiac-specific four year mortality were significantly lower. This was most pronounced in group B in which the total mortality was 45% and cardiovascular mortality was 47% less than in the placebo group. Similarly, mortality from cardiovascular disease in patients (groups A and B) with nontransmural ischaemia (ST-T changes) given hyaluronidase was significantly lower, with group B showing a 50% reduction. In the subsets of patients with late peaking of creatine kinase MB or those presenting with transmural electrocardiographic changes there was no difference in total mortality or deaths from cardiac disease between those given hyaluronidase and those given placebo. Hyaluronidase was associated with improved survival in patients with early peaking of plasma creatine kinase MB, suggesting the possibility of salvage of myocardium in patients who have early spontaneous reperfusion and possibly after therapeutic reperfusion.
1978年开展了一项多中心、随机、盲法研究,比较普萘洛尔或透明质酸酶与安慰剂对症状发作18小时内入院的急性心肌梗死患者的疗效。患者被随机分为A组,接受透明质酸酶、普萘洛尔或安慰剂治疗;若普萘洛尔禁忌,则分为B组,接受透明质酸酶或安慰剂治疗。透明质酸酶(每6小时给予500 U/kg,共48小时)对总体人群的死亡率或梗死面积无影响。由于血浆肌酸激酶MB早期峰值、非透壁性心电图改变或两者兼有的患者自发再灌注更为常见,因此对两个亚组的结果进行了重新分析:症状发作后血浆肌酸激酶峰值小于15小时的患者(早期峰值,n = 184)和症状发作后峰值大于15小时的患者(晚期峰值,n = 546)。透明质酸酶组和安慰剂组肌酸激酶MB活性峰值出现时间的分布相似。在给予透明质酸酶的早期峰值患者(A组和B组)中,总死亡率和心脏特异性四年死亡率显著降低。这在B组最为明显,其总死亡率比安慰剂组低45%,心血管死亡率低47%。同样,给予透明质酸酶的非透壁性缺血(ST-T改变)患者(A组和B组)的心血管疾病死亡率显著降低,B组降低了50%。在肌酸激酶MB晚期峰值或出现透壁性心电图改变的患者亚组中,给予透明质酸酶的患者与给予安慰剂的患者在总死亡率或心脏病死亡方面没有差异。透明质酸酶与血浆肌酸激酶MB早期峰值患者的生存率提高相关,提示在早期自发再灌注以及可能在治疗性再灌注后的患者中存在挽救心肌的可能性。