Schach Sonja, Gottwald Sebastian, Braun Daniel A
Faculty of Engingeering, Computer Science and Psychology, Institute of Neural Information Processing, Ulm University, Ulm, Germany.
Front Neurosci. 2018 Dec 14;12:932. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2018.00932. eCollection 2018.
Expected utility models are often used as a normative baseline for human performance in motor tasks. However, this baseline ignores computational costs that are incurred when searching for the optimal strategy. In contrast, bounded rational decision-theory provides a normative baseline that takes computational effort into account, as it describes optimal behavior of an agent with limited information-processing capacity to change a prior motor strategy (before information-processing) into a posterior strategy (after information-processing). Here, we devised a pointing task where subjects had restricted reaction and movement time. In particular, we manipulated the permissible reaction time as a proxy for the amount of computation allowed for planning the movements. Moreover, we tested three different distributions over the target locations to induce different prior strategies that would influence the amount of required information-processing. We found that movement endpoint precision generally decreases with limited planning time and that non-uniform prior probabilities allow for more precise movements toward high-probability targets. Considering these constraints in a bounded rational decision model, we found that subjects were generally close to bounded optimal. We conclude that bounded rational decision theory may be a promising normative framework to analyze human sensorimotor performance.
预期效用模型常被用作人类运动任务表现的规范基线。然而,该基线忽略了寻找最优策略时产生的计算成本。相比之下,有限理性决策理论提供了一个考虑计算成本的规范基线,因为它描述了具有有限信息处理能力的主体将先前运动策略(信息处理前)转变为后验策略(信息处理后)的最优行为。在此,我们设计了一个指向任务,其中受试者的反应和运动时间受到限制。具体而言,我们操纵允许的反应时间作为规划运动所需计算量的代理指标。此外,我们测试了目标位置上的三种不同分布,以诱导不同的先验策略,这些策略会影响所需信息处理的量。我们发现,运动终点精度通常会随着规划时间的限制而降低,并且非均匀先验概率允许朝着高概率目标进行更精确的运动。在有限理性决策模型中考虑这些约束条件后,我们发现受试者总体上接近有限最优。我们得出结论,有限理性决策理论可能是分析人类感觉运动表现的一个有前景的规范框架。