Gholizadeh Neda, Fuangrod Todsaporn, Greer Peter B, Lau Peter, Ramadan Saadallah, Simpson John
School of Health Sciences, University of Newcastle, Callaghan, NSW, Australia.
School of Medicine and Public Health, HRH Princess Chulabhorn College of Medical Science, Chulabhorn Royal Academy, Bangkok, Thailand.
Australas Phys Eng Sci Med. 2019 Mar;42(1):137-147. doi: 10.1007/s13246-019-00720-1. Epub 2019 Jan 14.
Magnetic resonance images (MRI) require intensity standardisation if they are used for the purpose of quantitative analysis as inherent variations in image intensity levels between different image sets are manifest due to technical factors. One approach is to standardise the image intensity values using a statistically applied biological reference tissue. The aim of this study is to compare the performance of differing candidate biological reference tissues for standardising T2WI intensity distributions. Fifty-one prostate cancer patients across two centres with different scanners were evaluated using the percentage interpatient coefficient of variation (%interCV) for four different biological references; femoral bone marrow, ischioanal fossa, obturator-internus muscle and bladder urine. The tissue with the highest reproducibility (lowest %interCV) in both centres was used for intensity standardisation of prostate T2WI using three different statistical measures (mean, Z-score, median + Interquartile Range). The performance of different standardisation methods was evaluated from the assessment of image intensity histograms and the percentage normalised root mean square error (%NRSME) of the healthy peripheral zone tissue. Ischioanal fossa as a reference tissue demonstrated the highest reproducibility with %interCV of 18.9 for centre1 and 11.2 for centre2. Using ischioanal fossa for statistical intensity standardisation and the median + Interquartile Range method demonstrated the lowest %NRMSE across centres for healthy peripheral zone tissues. This study demonstrates ischioanal fossa as a preferred reference tissue for standardising intensity values from T2WI of the prostate. Subsequent image standardisation using the median + Interquartile Range intensity of the reference tissue demonstrated a robust and reliable standardisation method for quantitative image assessment.
如果磁共振成像(MRI)用于定量分析,由于技术因素,不同图像集之间图像强度水平存在固有差异,因此需要进行强度标准化。一种方法是使用经统计学应用的生物参考组织对图像强度值进行标准化。本研究的目的是比较不同候选生物参考组织对T2WI强度分布进行标准化的性能。对两个中心使用不同扫描仪的51例前列腺癌患者,针对四种不同的生物参考组织(股骨骨髓、坐骨肛门窝、闭孔内肌和膀胱尿液),采用患者间变异系数百分比(%interCV)进行评估。在两个中心中具有最高再现性(最低%interCV)的组织用于使用三种不同的统计测量方法(均值、Z分数、中位数+四分位间距)对前列腺T2WI进行强度标准化。通过评估图像强度直方图和健康外周带组织的归一化均方根误差百分比(%NRSME)来评估不同标准化方法的性能。坐骨肛门窝作为参考组织表现出最高的再现性,中心1的%interCV为18.9,中心2为11.2。使用坐骨肛门窝进行统计强度标准化,且采用中位数+四分位间距方法时,各中心健康外周带组织的%NRMSE最低。本研究表明,坐骨肛门窝是前列腺T2WI强度值标准化的首选参考组织。随后使用参考组织的中位数+四分位间距强度进行图像标准化,证明了一种用于定量图像评估的稳健且可靠的标准化方法。