Department of Sustainable Food Production, Università Cattolica Del Sacro Cuore, Via Emilia Parmense 84, 29122 Piacenza, PC, Italy.
Department of Sustainable Food Production, Università Cattolica Del Sacro Cuore, Via Emilia Parmense 84, 29122 Piacenza, PC, Italy.
Sci Total Environ. 2019 Apr 10;660:622-630. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.12.267. Epub 2019 Jan 8.
In light of the considerable pressure exerted by food production on the environment, the assessment of the environmental burdens of dietary choices has recently gained interest among the scientific community. Several studies based on life cycle thinking approach agreed that a transition from an omnivorous to either a vegan or vegetarian diets would reduce the environmental impact associated with food consumption. The majority of the studies set the system boundaries up to the retail, excluding the consumption phase and generally do not account for uncertainties. The aim of the present study was to assess how personal consumption choices and behaviour can affect the greenhouse gas emissions generated by three balanced dietary patterns (omnivorous, vegetarian and vegan), defined on the basis of nutritional recommendations for an average Italian man. It took into consideration the uncertainties associated with three elements, namely the greenhouse gas emissions due to the production of the food items, the emissions associated with cooking and the food wasted by consumers. The results of the study highlighted that, despite the higher share of greenhouse gas emissions of the supply chain stages prior to consumption (66%-74% of the total emissions), domestic behaviours have an important influence of the total greenhouse gas emissions of the diet, which can offset the lower GHG emissions due to the choice of vegetable-origin foods. In fact, 15%-21% of the total emissions are associated to the cooking phase and 11%-13% to the food waste generation. Therefore, this study remarks the importance of adopting a cradle to grave perspective when assessing the environmental burden of dietary patterns and emphasises the central role of consumers in the definition of low GHG-emitting dietary patterns.
鉴于食品生产对环境造成的巨大压力,最近科学界对饮食选择的环境负担评估产生了兴趣。基于生命周期思维方法的几项研究一致认为,从杂食转变为素食或纯素食会降低与食物消费相关的环境影响。大多数研究将系统边界设定在零售层面,不包括消费阶段,并且通常不考虑不确定性。本研究旨在评估个人消费选择和行为如何影响三种均衡饮食模式(杂食、素食和纯素食)产生的温室气体排放,这些模式是根据意大利男性的平均营养建议定义的。它考虑了与三个因素相关的不确定性,即食物生产产生的温室气体排放、烹饪产生的排放以及消费者浪费的食物。研究结果表明,尽管消费前供应链阶段的温室气体排放份额较高(占总排放量的 66%-74%),但国内行为对饮食的总温室气体排放有重要影响,可以抵消由于选择植物性食物而导致的较低温室气体排放。事实上,总排放量的 15%-21%与烹饪阶段有关,11%-13%与食物浪费有关。因此,本研究表明在评估饮食模式的环境负担时采用从摇篮到坟墓的视角的重要性,并强调消费者在定义低温室气体排放饮食模式方面的核心作用。