Department of Preventive Dental Sciences, College of Dentistry, Prince Sattam bin Abdulaziz University, Alkharj, Saudi Arabia.
Photodiagnosis Photodyn Ther. 2019 Mar;25:349-353. doi: 10.1016/j.pdpdt.2019.01.018. Epub 2019 Jan 14.
To systematically review the literature regarding the antimicrobial effects of photodynamic therapy (PDT) on multi-bacterial species and the possible surface alterations of dental implants as a result of PDT.
The addressed focused question was: "Does PDT show antimicrobial efficacy against multi-bacterial species colonization and result in surface alteration on dental implants?" Electronic databases including MEDLINE and EMBASE up to and including December 2018 were searched.
Seven studies were included. Two studies used a total of 110 titanium dental implants, while 1 study included a total of 72 zirconia dental implants. Three studies investigated the antimicrobial PDT effects on titanium discs, while 1 study used titanium plates with germanium prisms. All in-vitro studies used diode laser. Energy fluence was reported only in 2 studies. Power output and density were 100 mW (mW) and 150 mW cm, respectively. All in-vitro studies reported the multibacterial species outcomes after the application of antimicrobial PDT. All studies showed a significant reduction in the bacterial load. Only two studies reported the outcomes of microstructural changes on the titanium surface, in which both studies did not report any significant alterations on the titanium implants or discs with the application of PDT.
This systematic review demonstrated significant reduction in the bacterial load but inconclusive findings regarding structural alterations on the titanium surface with the use of PDT. The results of this review should be considered preliminary and further in-vitro studies with standardized laser parameters are needed to obtain strong conclusions.
系统回顾关于光动力疗法(PDT)对多细菌物种的抗菌效果以及 PDT 对牙种植体表面可能产生的改变的文献。
本次研究的聚焦问题是:“PDT 是否对多细菌物种的定植具有抗菌功效,并导致牙种植体表面发生改变?”检索了截至 2018 年 12 月的 MEDLINE 和 EMBASE 等电子数据库。
共纳入 7 项研究。其中 2 项研究共使用了 110 枚钛质牙种植体,1 项研究共使用了 72 枚氧化锆牙种植体。3 项研究调查了 PDT 对钛片的抗菌效果,1 项研究使用了带有锗棱镜的钛板。所有的体外研究均使用二极管激光。仅有 2 项研究报告了能量密度。功率输出和密度分别为 100mW(毫瓦)和 150mW/cm。所有的体外研究均报告了应用抗菌 PDT 后多细菌物种的结果。所有研究均显示细菌负荷显著降低。仅有 2 项研究报告了钛表面微观结构变化的结果,其中两项研究均未报告 PDT 应用后钛种植体或钛片有任何明显改变。
本系统评价显示,PDT 可显著降低细菌负荷,但关于 PDT 对钛表面结构改变的结论尚无定论。本研究结果应被视为初步结果,需要进一步开展具有标准化激光参数的体外研究,以得出更有力的结论。