Wang W, Zhan P, Xie Q, Hu H D, Wang Y C, Yuan Q, Zhang Q, Chi C Z, Xu C H, Song Y
The Endoscopic Center of Nanjing Chest Hospital, School of Medicine, Southeast University, Nanjing 210029, China.
Radiology Department of Nanjing Chest Hospital, School of Medicine, Southeast University, Nanjing 210029, China.
Zhonghua Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2019 Jan 8;99(2):93-98. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.0376-2491.2019.02.004.
To evaluate the diagnostic efficiency of combination of CT multiplane 3D reconstruction (CT-3DR), radial endobronchial ultrasound (R-EBUS), and rapid on-site evaluation (ROSE) for peripheral solitary pulmonary nodules (SPN). A total of 176 patients with peripheral solitary pulmonary nodule were included from the Nanjing Chest Hospital from March 2016 to March 2017. According to different methods, all the patients were divided into four groups: EG (i.e. R-EBUS+Guiding sheath (GS))group, CTE (i.e. CT-3DR+R-EBUS) group, RE (i.e. ROSE+R-EBUS) group, and triad (i.e. CT-3DR+ROSE+R-EBUS) group. Sampling was performed by transbronchial lung biopsy. The diagnostic yield and complications, procedure time and influencing factors in these four groups were retrospectively analyzed. The value of ROSE and combination of CT-3DR+ROSE+R-EBUS in diagnosis for SPN also was evaluated. The diagnostic yield for total SPNs among four groups were 70.5% in EG group, 70.0% in CTE group, 69.0% in RE group and 74.0% in triad group, respectively. There was no significant difference among four groups (all 0.05). The procedure time of EG group, CTE group, RE group and triad group were (34.0±6.3), (26.6±6.8), (27.2±7.8) and (19.4±5.4) min, respectively. The procedure time was the shortest in triad group compared with the other three groups (all 0.001) and the time of CTE and RE groups were significantly shorter than the EG group (both 0.001). The coincidence rates of CT-3DR navigation position with target bronchus were 87.5% in CTE group and 90.0% in triad group with no significant difference between these two groups (0.05). The diagnostic yield was higher for SPNs with their major diameter ≥2 cm than those with their major diameter2 cm in all four groups (all 0.05). The positive diagnostic yield was higher with ultrasonic probe located within SPN lesion than the probe adjacent to or deviated the lesion in all four groups (all 0.05). In EG and RE groups, for those SPNs with the distance between the lesion and pleura≥2 cm, the diagnostic yield were higher than those withe the distance<2 cm (0.05) but no similar phenomenon was observed in CTE and triad groups. No significant correlation was detected between the diagnostic yield and the density of SPN lesions among four groups (all 0.05). ROSE was used in RE and triad groups. The coincidence rate of ROSE with histopathology was 82.6% and the value of Kappa was 0.608. The diagnostic sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value of ROSE were 0.818, 0.846, 0.931 and 0.647, respectively. CT-3DR navigation and ROSE help to improve the diagnostic efficiency of R-EBUS for SPN. Combination of CT-3DR, R-EBUS and ROSE is of diagnostic value for peripheral SPN and with significant shortening of procedure time.
评估CT多平面三维重建(CT-3DR)、径向支气管内超声(R-EBUS)及快速现场评价(ROSE)联合应用对周围型孤立性肺结节(SPN)的诊断效能。2016年3月至2017年3月期间,纳入南京市胸科医院176例周围型孤立性肺结节患者。根据不同方法,将所有患者分为四组:EG组(即R-EBUS+引导鞘管(GS))、CTE组(即CT-3DR+R-EBUS)、RE组(即ROSE+R-EBUS)和三联组(即CT-3DR+ROSE+R-EBUS)。采用经支气管肺活检进行采样。回顾性分析这四组的诊断阳性率及并发症、操作时间和影响因素。同时评估ROSE以及CT-3DR+ROSE+R-EBUS联合应用对SPN的诊断价值。四组中SPN的总体诊断阳性率分别为:EG组70.5%、CTE组70.0%、RE组69.0%、三联组74.0%。四组间差异无统计学意义(均P>0.05)。EG组、CTE组、RE组和三联组的操作时间分别为(34.0±6.3)、(26.6±6.8)、(27.2±7.8)和(19.4±5.4)分钟。三联组操作时间最短,与其他三组相比差异均有统计学意义(均P<0.001),CTE组和RE组的时间均显著短于EG组(均P<0.001)。CTE组CT-3DR导航定位与目标支气管的符合率为87.5%,三联组为90.0%,两组间差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。四组中,最大径≥2 cm的SPN诊断阳性率均高于最大径<2 cm的SPN(均P<0.05)。四组中超声探头位于SPN病灶内时的阳性诊断率均高于探头邻近或偏离病灶时(均P<0.05)。在EG组和RE组中,病灶与胸膜距离≥2 cm的SPN诊断阳性率高于距离<2 cm者(P<0.05),但CTE组和三联组未观察到类似现象。四组中诊断阳性率与SPN病灶密度之间均未检测到显著相关性(均P>0.05)。RE组和三联组应用ROSE。ROSE与组织病理学的符合率为82.6%,Kappa值为0.608。ROSE的诊断敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值和阴性预测值分别为0.818、0.846、0.931和0.647。CT-3DR导航和ROSE有助于提高R-EBUS对SPN的诊断效能。CT-3DR、R-EBUS和ROSE联合应用对周围型SPN具有诊断价值,且显著缩短操作时间。