Research Institute for Sport and Exercise Science, Liverpool John Moores University, Liverpool, L3 3AF, UK.
Sports Med. 2019 Feb;49(Suppl 1):25-37. doi: 10.1007/s40279-018-1005-2.
Sport nutrition is one of the fastest growing and evolving disciplines of sport and exercise science, demonstrated by a 4-fold increase in the number of research papers between 2012 and 2018. Indeed, the scope of contemporary nutrition-related research could range from discovery of novel nutrient-sensitive cell-signalling pathways to the assessment of the effects of sports drinks on exercise performance. For the sport nutrition practitioner, the goal is to translate innovations in research to develop and administer practical interventions that contribute to the delivery of winning performances. Accordingly, step one in the translation of research to practice should always be a well-structured critique of the translational potential of the existing scientific evidence. To this end, we present an operational framework (the "Paper-2-Podium Matrix") that provides a checklist of criteria for which to prompt the critical evaluation of performance nutrition-related research papers. In considering the (1) research context, (2) participant characteristics, (3) research design, (4) dietary and exercise controls, (5) validity and reliability of exercise performance tests, (6) data analytics, (7) feasibility of application, (8) risk/reward and (9) timing of the intervention, we aimed to provide a time-efficient framework to aid practitioners in their scientific appraisal of research. Ultimately, it is the combination of boldness of reform (i.e. innovations in research) and quality of execution (i.e. ease of administration of practical solutions) that is most likely to deliver the transition from paper to podium.
运动营养是运动和锻炼科学中发展最快和不断演变的学科之一,这一点可以从 2012 年至 2018 年期间研究论文数量增加了 4 倍得到证明。实际上,当代与营养相关的研究范围可以从发现新型营养敏感细胞信号通路到评估运动饮料对运动表现的影响。对于运动营养从业者来说,目标是将研究创新转化为开发和管理实用干预措施,以促进取得胜利的表现。因此,将研究转化为实践的第一步应该始终是对现有科学证据的转化潜力进行精心结构的批判。为此,我们提出了一个操作框架(“论文-领奖台矩阵”),该框架提供了一套标准清单,用于提示对与表现营养相关的研究论文进行批判性评估。在考虑(1)研究背景、(2)参与者特征、(3)研究设计、(4)饮食和运动控制、(5)运动表现测试的有效性和可靠性、(6)数据分析、(7)应用可行性、(8)风险/回报和(9)干预时间时,我们旨在提供一个高效的框架,帮助从业者对研究进行科学评估。最终,最有可能实现从论文到领奖台的转变的是改革的大胆程度(即研究中的创新)和执行的质量(即实用解决方案的易于管理)的结合。