Gouweloos-Trines Juul, Te Brake Hans, Sijbrandij Marit, Boelen Paul A, Brewin Chris R, Kleber Rolf J
Knowledge Center Impact, Arq Psychotrauma Expert Group, Diemen, The Netherlands.
Department of Clinical Psychology, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Eur J Psychotraumatol. 2019 Jan 14;10(1):1554406. doi: 10.1080/20008198.2018.1554406. eCollection 2019.
: In 2009, an aeroplane crashed near Amsterdam. To remedy unmet mental health needs, active outreach was used to identify victims at risk for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression. : The active outreach strategy was evaluated by examining the accuracy of screening methods in predicting PTSD and depression, self-reported treatment needs, and the extent to which perceived treatment needs predict trajectories of PTSD. : In 112 adult survivors, semi-structured telephone interviews were held at 2 (T1, = 76), 9 (T2, = 77) and 44 months (T3, = 55) after the crash. The Trauma Screening Questionnaire (TSQ) and the Patient Health Questionnaire-2 (PHQ-2) measured symptoms of PTSD and depression, respectively. At T3, a clinical interview assessed PTSD and depression diagnoses. Based on the TSQ scores at the three time-points, participants were grouped into five 'trajectories': resilient ( = 38), chronic ( = 30), recovery ( = 9), delayed onset ( = 9) and relapse ( = 3). : The TSQ accurately predicted PTSD at T3 (sensitivity: .75-1.00; specificity: .79-.90). The PHQ-2 showed modest accuracy (sensitivity: .38-.89; specificity: .67-.90). Both measures provided low positive predictive values (TSQ: 0.57; PHQ-2: .50 at T3). A number of participants reported unmet treatment needs (T1: 32.9%; T2: 19.5%; T3: 10.9%). Reporting unmet needs at T2 was more often assigned to a chronic PTSD trajectory compared to reporting no needs ( < .01). : The prevalence of unmet needs at 44 months after the crash within a chronic PTSD trajectory indicated that active outreach may be warranted. Nevertheless, although the TSQ was accurate, many participants screening positive did not develop PTSD. This implies that, although active outreach may benefit those with unmet needs, it also has its costs in terms of possible unnecessary clinical assessments.
2009年,一架飞机在阿姆斯特丹附近坠毁。为了满足未得到满足的心理健康需求,采用了主动外展服务来识别有创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)和抑郁症风险的受害者。
通过检查筛查方法在预测PTSD和抑郁症方面的准确性、自我报告的治疗需求以及感知到的治疗需求预测PTSD轨迹的程度,对主动外展策略进行了评估。
在112名成年幸存者中,在坠机后的2个月(T1,n = 76)、9个月(T2,n = 77)和44个月(T3,n = 55)进行了半结构化电话访谈。创伤筛查问卷(TSQ)和患者健康问卷-2(PHQ-2)分别测量PTSD和抑郁症的症状。在T3时,通过临床访谈评估PTSD和抑郁症的诊断。根据三个时间点的TSQ分数,将参与者分为五个“轨迹”:恢复力强(n = 38)、慢性(n = 30)、恢复(n = 9)、延迟发作(n = 9)和复发(n = 3)。
TSQ在T3时准确预测了PTSD(敏感性:0.75 - 1.00;特异性:0.79 - 0.90)。PHQ-2的准确性一般(敏感性:0.38 - 0.89;特异性:0.67 - 0.90)。两种测量方法的阳性预测值都较低(TSQ:0.57;PHQ-2在T3时为0.50)。许多参与者报告有未得到满足的治疗需求(T1:32.9%;T2:19.5%;T3:10.9%)。与报告无需求相比,在T2时报告有未满足需求的情况更常被归为慢性PTSD轨迹(p < 0.01)。
在慢性PTSD轨迹中,坠机后44个月未满足需求的患病率表明主动外展服务可能是必要的。然而,尽管TSQ很准确,但许多筛查呈阳性的参与者并未患上PTSD。这意味着,虽然主动外展服务可能使有未满足需求的人受益,但就可能不必要的临床评估而言,它也有成本。