School of Allied Health, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland.
HSE Dublin South West, Dublin, Ireland.
Disabil Rehabil. 2020 Aug;42(16):2232-2242. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2018.1555623. Epub 2019 Jan 29.
: Stuttering is a chronic communication disorder resulting in challenging life experiences for many individuals. This review aimed to integrate qualitative findings on the lived experiences of people who stutter and identify implications for rehabilitation.: A systematic literature search of electronic databases for studies published since 2000 was completed to identify research papers that used qualitative methods to explore the lived experiences of adults who stutter. Forty-five papers were read in full and a final seventeen papers were synthesised using a meta-ethnographic approach.: Five themes are described: (i) Avoidance is used to manage stuttering; (ii) Stuttering unfavourably impacts employment experiences; (iii) Stuttering shapes self-identity; (iv) Stuttering leads to negative reactions; and (v) Stuttering impacts relationships adversely.: This review identifies the profound and predominantly negative impact that stuttering has on individuals' experiences. Avoidance is a commonly used strategy to manage stuttering with further negative consequences for the individual. To promote person-centred care and enhance treatment outcomes, clinicians should be cognizant of the profound impact of stuttering on the individual's life experience and incorporate targeted goals to reflect this when intervening.IMPLICATIONS FOR REHABILITATIONClinicians should be aware of and understand the extent of the impact of stuttering on an individual's life which is typified by various forms of avoidance and challenges in a number of domains including employment, identity formation, relationship development and others' perceptions of the person who stutters.An impairment-based approach to stuttering treatment with adults focusing on the overt aspects of stuttering (i.e., speech behaviours) is not holistic and does not do justice to the spectrum of covert features such as avoidance, and internalised thoughts and feelings that are associated with the condition. Therefore, the adoption of a holistic approach to stuttering intervention is recommended.An understanding of adults' lived experience of stuttering has the potential to inform programme developments for children and adolescents with the same condition and thus employ preventative strategies to reduce the development of negative life experiences at an earlier age.Clinicians should engage with the field of disability studies to strengthen their practice and consider their role in addressing socially-imposed barriers such as negative attitudes impacting on people who stutter.
口吃是一种慢性言语障碍,给许多人带来了充满挑战的生活体验。本综述旨在整合关于口吃者生活体验的定性研究结果,并确定其对口吃康复的意义。
系统检索了自 2000 年以来发表的电子数据库中的研究论文,以确定使用定性方法探索口吃成年人生活体验的研究论文。阅读了 45 篇全文,并使用元民族志方法综合了最终的 17 篇论文。
(i)避免策略用于管理口吃;(ii)口吃严重影响就业经历;(iii)口吃塑造自我认同;(iv)口吃导致负面反应;(v)口吃对人际关系产生不利影响。
本综述确定了口吃对个体体验的深远和主要负面影响。避免是管理口吃的常用策略,这会对个体产生进一步的负面影响。为了促进以患者为中心的护理并提高治疗效果,临床医生应该意识到口吃对个体生活体验的深远影响,并在干预时纳入有针对性的目标来反映这一点。
对口吃康复的意义
临床医生应该了解并理解口吃对个体生活的影响程度,这种影响表现在各种形式的回避和在许多领域的挑战,包括就业、身份形成、关系发展和其他人对口吃者的看法。
以成人的显性口吃(即言语行为)为重点的基于损伤的口吃治疗方法是不全面的,也不能公正地对待回避等隐性特征,以及与该疾病相关的内在思想和感受。因此,建议采用全面的口吃干预方法。
对口吃者生活体验的理解有可能为患有相同疾病的儿童和青少年的项目发展提供信息,并因此采用预防策略,在更早的年龄减少消极生活体验的发展。
临床医生应该参与残疾研究领域,以加强他们的实践,并考虑在解决社会强加的障碍方面发挥作用,如对口吃者产生负面影响的消极态度。