Key Laboratory of Oil Crop Biology of the Ministry of Agriculture, Oil Crops Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Wuhan, 430062, Hubei, China.
Development Center of Science and Technology, Ministry of Agriculture of People's Republic of China, Beijing, 100025, China.
Anal Bioanal Chem. 2019 Mar;411(9):1729-1744. doi: 10.1007/s00216-019-01576-w. Epub 2019 Feb 1.
The enforcement of GMO labeling regulations requires validated analytical methods and certified reference materials (CRMs). The early labeling regulations stipulated that the GMO content should be expressed as percentage, but did not specify what unit this percentage referred to. Two reference systems, using mass fraction and copy number ratio as measurement units, individually, are established for GMO analysis using different metrological traceability chains. Three types of CRMs, powder CRMs certified for mass fractions, genomic DNA CRMs, and plasmid DNA CRMs certified for copy number ratios, were developed for calibration and quality control. The type, certification, and measurement unit commutability of current GMO CRMs are presented and discussed in this paper. Both existing reference systems are facing a metrological challenge, although later EU regulations specified that the measurement unit of GMO content must be expressed in mass fraction and recommended to convert one unit into another by introducing a conversion factor, further efforts are required to explore which reference system is more metrologically sound. The determination of conversion factor per CRM batch is recommended to be based on the pure CRMs produced from pure GM materials, which is expected to be the best choice for calibration of PCR measurement results.
转基因生物标签法规的执行需要经过验证的分析方法和认证的参考物质(CRM)。早期的标签法规规定,转基因生物含量应以百分比表示,但未具体说明该百分比所指的单位。对于使用不同计量溯源链的转基因生物分析,分别建立了以质量分数和拷贝数比为测量单位的两个参考体系。开发了三种类型的 CRM,即经质量分数认证的粉末 CRM、经拷贝数比认证的基因组 DNA CRM 和质粒 DNA CRM,用于校准和质量控制。本文介绍并讨论了当前转基因生物 CRM 的类型、认证和测量单位的可互换性。尽管后来的欧盟法规规定,转基因生物含量的测量单位必须以质量分数表示,并建议通过引入转换因子将一个单位转换为另一个单位,但这两个参考体系都面临计量挑战,需要进一步努力探讨哪个参考体系在计量上更为合理。建议每批 CRM 批次的转换因子的确定都基于从纯转基因材料中生产的纯 CRM,这有望成为校准 PCR 测量结果的最佳选择。