Imaging Genetics Center of the Mark and Mary Stevens Institute for Neuroimaging & Informatics, Keck School of Medicine, University of Southern California, Marina del Rey, CA.
Durham VA Medical Center, Durham, NC.
J Neuroimaging. 2019 May;29(3):335-343. doi: 10.1111/jon.12600. Epub 2019 Feb 3.
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a heterogeneous condition associated with a range of brain imaging abnormalities. Early life stress (ELS) contributes to this heterogeneity, but we do not know how a history of ELS influences traditionally defined brain signatures of PTSD. Here, we used a novel machine learning method - evolving partitions to improve classification (EPIC) - to identify shared and unique structural neuroimaging markers of ELS and PTSD in 97 combat-exposed military veterans.
We used EPIC with repeated cross-validation (CV) to determine how combinations of cortical thickness, surface area, and subcortical brain volumes could contribute to classification of PTSD (n = 40) versus controls (n = 57), and classification of ELS within the PTSD (ELS n = 16; ELS n = 24) and control groups (ELS n = 16; ELS n = 41). Additional inputs included intracranial volume, age, sex, adult trauma, and depression.
On average, EPIC classified PTSD with 69% accuracy (SD = 5%), and ELS with 64% accuracy in the PTSD group (SD = 10%), and 62% accuracy in controls (SD = 6%). EPIC selected unique sets of individual features that classified each group with 75-85% accuracy in post hoc analyses; combinations of regions marginally improved classification from the individual atlas-defined brain regions. Across analyses, surface area in the right posterior cingulate was the only variable that was repeatedly selected as an important feature for classification of PTSD and ELS.
EPIC revealed unique patterns of features that distinguished PTSD and ELS in this sample of combat-exposed military veterans, which may represent distinct biotypes of stress-related neuropathology.
创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)是一种与多种大脑影像学异常相关的异质性疾病。早期生活压力(ELS)促成了这种异质性,但我们不知道 ELS 病史如何影响 PTSD 的传统定义的大脑特征。在这里,我们使用一种新的机器学习方法——不断进化的分区以提高分类(EPIC)——来识别 97 名经历过战斗的退伍军人中 ELS 和 PTSD 的共同和独特的结构性神经影像学标志物。
我们使用 EPIC 进行重复交叉验证(CV),以确定皮质厚度、表面积和皮质下脑体积的组合如何有助于 PTSD(n=40)与对照组(n=57)的分类,以及 PTSD 组(ELS n=16;ELS n=24)和对照组(ELS n=16;ELS n=41)中 ELS 的分类。其他输入包括颅内体积、年龄、性别、成人创伤和抑郁。
平均而言,EPIC 在 PTSD 中的分类准确率为 69%(标准差[SD]=5%),在 PTSD 组中的 ELS 分类准确率为 64%(SD=10%),在对照组中的 ELS 分类准确率为 62%(SD=6%)。EPIC 选择了独特的个体特征集,在事后分析中,这些特征集以 75-85%的准确率对每个组进行分类;与个体图谱定义的大脑区域相比,区域组合略微提高了分类的准确性。在所有分析中,右侧后扣带回的表面积是唯一被反复选择为 PTSD 和 ELS 分类的重要特征变量。
EPIC 揭示了 PTSD 和 ELS 在这个经历过战斗的退伍军人样本中的独特特征模式,这可能代表了与应激相关的神经病理学的不同生物类型。