Prescrire Int. 2016 Nov;25(176):272-277.
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a respiratory disorder characterised by largely irreversible changes in air flow due to irritants such as tobacco smoke. Patients with COPD experience acute exacerbations. Severe disease may progress to chronic respiratory failure. We reviewed the literature on basic medications available for COPD, using the standard Prescrire methodology. There are few clinical data on treatment of mild COPD. Regular medication is not necessary for patients who do not have recurrent symptoms. Eliminating exposure to cigarette smoke and other irritants such as workplace irritants, is the only measure known to improve the outcome of COPD. Evaluation of inhaled short-acting beta-2 agonists is based mainly on short-term trials. These drugs have been shown to improve dyspnoea. Salmeterol and formoterol, two long-acting beta-2 agonists, have been extensively evaluated in symptomatic patients. Compared with no treatment, these drugs reduce breathlessness and acute exacerbations, preventing about two hospital admissions per 100 patients with moderate to severe COPD treated for 7 months. Indacaterol and olodateroldo not have a better harm-benefit balance. Inhaled beta-2 agonists occasionally provoke cardiovascular disorders. No excess mortality has been reported among the thousands of COPD patients included in clinical trials. There Is little evidence that ipratropium, an inhaled short-acting anti-muscarinic bronchodilator, improves COPD symptoms. A risk of Increased mortality among COPD patients treated with ipratroplum cannot be ruled out. Tiotroplum, an inhaled long-acting antimuscarinic bronchodilator, has been extensively evaluated In COPD. Tiotroplum has symptomatic efficacy in COPD, reducing dyspnoea and acute exacerbations. Tiotroplum had no tangible advantages over long-acting beta-2 agonists in seven randomised trials including more than 12 000 patients. Glycopyrronium and aclidinium, two other Inhaled long-acting antimuscarinics, do not appear to be more effective. Tiotroplum, like other inhaled anti-muscarinics, has antimuscarinic adverse effects including cardiac, visual and buccal disorders. Glycopyronium may carry a higher risk of serious cardiovascular effects. Combination of an antimuscarinic with an inhaled beta-2 agonist improves symptoms in 7% to 10% of patients. In patients with one or two COPD exacerbations per year, adding an Inhaled corticosterold (beclometa- sone, budesonide or fluticasone) to a long-acting beta-2 agonist prevents about 1 exacerbation during 3 to 4 years of treatment. Inhaled corticosteroids can cause pneumonia, candidiasis, dysphonia and adrenal Insufficiency. Fluticasone seems to have more adverse effects than other inhaled corticosterolds. Theophylline has uncertain efficacy on symptoms of COPD. This drug has a narrow therapeutic index and carries a risk of serious adverse effects. It should not be used in COPD. Long-term treatment with roflumilast or oral corticosteroids has an unfavourable harm-benefit balance in COPD. In practice, in 2016, the first measure in COPD is to eliminate exposure to the irritant, most often tobacco. Drugs used in COPD have only modest, mainly symptomatic efficacy. Treatment should be adapted to symptoms and the frequency of exacerbations: a short-acting beta-2 agonist should be tried first, then replaced by an inhaled long-acting bronchodilator, or possibly tiotropium, when its effect is too short-lived. An inhaled corticosteroid can be added if symptoms persist or exacerbations are frequent.
慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)是一种呼吸系统疾病,其特征是由于烟草烟雾等刺激物导致气流出现很大程度的不可逆变化。COPD患者会经历急性加重期。严重的疾病可能会发展为慢性呼吸衰竭。我们使用标准的Prescrire方法,回顾了有关COPD可用基础药物的文献。关于轻度COPD治疗的临床数据很少。对于没有复发症状的患者,常规用药并非必要。消除接触香烟烟雾和其他刺激物(如工作场所的刺激物)是已知的改善COPD预后的唯一措施。吸入短效β-2激动剂的评估主要基于短期试验。这些药物已被证明可改善呼吸困难。沙美特罗和福莫特罗这两种长效β-2激动剂,已在有症状的患者中进行了广泛评估。与未治疗相比,这些药物可减轻呼吸困难和急性加重,每100例中度至重度COPD患者接受7个月治疗可预防约2次住院。茚达特罗和奥达特罗的利弊平衡并无优势。吸入β-2激动剂偶尔会引发心血管疾病。在纳入临床试验的数千例COPD患者中,未报告有额外的死亡率。几乎没有证据表明吸入短效抗毒蕈碱支气管扩张剂异丙托溴铵能改善COPD症状。不能排除使用异丙托溴铵治疗的COPD患者死亡率增加的风险。噻托溴铵是一种吸入长效抗毒蕈碱支气管扩张剂,已在COPD中进行了广泛评估。噻托溴铵对COPD有症状改善作用,可减轻呼吸困难和急性加重。在包括超过12000例患者的7项随机试验中,噻托溴铵与长效β-2激动剂相比没有明显优势。格隆溴铵和阿地溴铵这两种其他吸入长效抗毒蕈碱药物似乎效果并不更好。噻托溴铵与其他吸入抗毒蕈碱药物一样,有抗毒蕈碱不良反应,包括心脏、视觉和口腔方面的问题。格隆溴铵可能有更高的严重心血管效应风险。抗毒蕈碱药物与吸入β-2激动剂联合使用可使7%至10%的患者症状改善。对于每年有一两次COPD加重的患者,在长效β-2激动剂基础上加用吸入糖皮质激素(倍氯米松、布地奈德或氟替卡松)在3至4年的治疗期间可预防约1次加重。吸入糖皮质激素可导致肺炎、念珠菌病、声音嘶哑和肾上腺功能不全。氟替卡松似乎比其他吸入糖皮质激素有更多不良反应。茶碱对COPD症状的疗效不确定。这种药物治疗指数窄,有严重不良反应风险。不应在COPD中使用。罗氟司特或口服糖皮质激素的长期治疗在COPD中的利弊平衡不利。实际上,在2016年,COPD的首要措施是消除接触刺激物,最常见的是烟草。用于COPD的药物只有适度的、主要是症状改善方面的疗效。治疗应根据症状和加重频率进行调整:应首先尝试使用短效β-2激动剂,当其效果持续时间过短时,可换成吸入长效支气管扩张剂,或可能换成噻托溴铵。如果症状持续或加重频繁,可加用吸入糖皮质激素。