Vanderbilt Brain Institute, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA.
Peabody College of Education, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA.
Cereb Cortex. 2019 Dec 17;29(11):4877-4888. doi: 10.1093/cercor/bhz025.
Neurobiological studies of discourse comprehension have almost exclusively focused on narrative comprehension. However, successful engagement in modern society, particularly in educational settings, also requires comprehension with an aim to learn new information (i.e., "expository comprehension"). Despite its prevalence, no studies to date have neurobiologically characterized expository comprehension as compared with narrative. In the current study, we used functional magnetic resonance imaging in typically developing children to test whether different genres require specialized brain networks. In addition to expected activations in language and comprehension areas in the default mode network (DMN), expository comprehension required significantly greater activation in the frontoparietal control network (FPN) than narrative comprehension, and relied significantly less on posterior regions in the DMN. Functional connectivity analysis revealed that, compared with narrative, the FPN robustly correlated with the DMN, and this inter-network communication was higher with increased reading expertise. These findings suggest that, relative to narrative comprehension, expository comprehension shows (1) a unique configuration of the DMN, potentially to support non-social comprehension processes, and (2) increased utilization of top-down regions to help support goal-directed comprehension processes in the DMN. More generally, our findings reveal that different types of discourse-level comprehension place diverse neural demands on the developing brain.
神经生物学对语篇理解的研究几乎完全集中在叙事理解上。然而,要成功融入现代社会,尤其是在教育环境中,还需要理解以获取新信息(即“说明文理解”)。尽管说明文在现代社会中非常普遍,但迄今为止,尚无研究从神经生物学角度对说明文理解与叙事理解进行比较。在当前的研究中,我们使用功能磁共振成像技术对正常发育的儿童进行了测试,以检验不同体裁是否需要专门的大脑网络。除了在默认模式网络(DMN)中的语言和理解区域的预期激活外,说明文理解比叙事理解需要显著更多的额顶控制网络(FPN)激活,并且对 DMN 中的后区的依赖程度显著降低。功能连接分析显示,与叙事相比,FPN 与 DMN 之间具有更强的相关性,并且随着阅读专业知识的增加,这种网络间的通讯也更高。这些发现表明,与叙事理解相比,说明文理解表现出(1)DMN 的独特配置,可能有助于支持非社交理解过程,以及(2)更多地利用自上而下的区域来帮助支持 DMN 中的目标导向理解过程。更普遍地说,我们的研究结果表明,不同类型的语篇水平理解对发育中的大脑有不同的神经需求。