Haeder Simon F
Department of Political Science, John D. Rockefeller IV School of Policy & Politics, West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV, USA.
Health Serv Res Manag Epidemiol. 2019 Mar 27;6:2333392818824472. doi: 10.1177/2333392818824472. eCollection 2019 Jan-Dec.
Medicare Advantage enrollment has seen tremendous growth over the past decade. However, we know comparatively little about the experience of beneficiaries in the program. Our knowledge of Medicare Advantage provider networks is particularly limited. This article is one of the first major assessments of the issue. It seeks to answer 3 important questions. First, are Medicare Advantage plan networks made up of higher quality providers? Second, how significant are the network restrictions imposed by Medicare Advantage plans with regard to access to higher quality providers? And finally, how much provider choice are Medicare Advantage beneficiaries left with? To assess these questions, I utilize geospatial data and individual provider quality measures for cardiologists, endocrinologists, and obstetricians and gynecologists from California. I find that Medicare Advantage beneficiaries generally do well in large metropolitan areas compared to traditional Medicare. However, there are concerns for those in micropolitan and rural areas, and even those in standard metropolitan areas, at times. Crucially, the connection between provider quality and networks can only be fully understood when connected to assessments of provider access. These findings also raise questions about how we think about provider networks and the adequacy of current approaches to network regulation.
在过去十年中,医疗保险优待计划的参保人数有了巨大增长。然而,我们对该计划中受益人的体验了解相对较少。我们对医疗保险优待计划的医疗服务提供网络的了解尤其有限。本文是对该问题的首批重大评估之一。它试图回答三个重要问题。第一,医疗保险优待计划的网络是否由更高质量的医疗服务提供者组成?第二,医疗保险优待计划对获得更高质量医疗服务提供者所施加的网络限制有多严重?最后,医疗保险优待计划的受益人还剩下多少医疗服务提供者可供选择?为了评估这些问题,我利用了地理空间数据以及加利福尼亚州心脏病专家、内分泌学家、妇产科医生的个体医疗服务提供者质量指标。我发现,与传统医疗保险相比,医疗保险优待计划的受益人在大都市区总体表现良好。然而,对于那些生活在微都市和农村地区的人,甚至有时对于那些生活在标准大都市区的人来说,仍存在担忧。至关重要的是,只有将医疗服务提供者质量与网络评估联系起来,才能全面理解医疗服务提供者质量与网络之间的关系。这些发现也引发了关于我们如何看待医疗服务提供者网络以及当前网络监管方法是否充分的问题。