School of Public Health in Southeast University, 87 Hunan Rd, Nanjing 210009, China.
Department of Vaccine Clinical Evaluation, Jiangsu Provincial Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Jiangsu, China.
Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2019;15(11):2769-2777. doi: 10.1080/21645515.2019.1602435. Epub 2019 May 3.
The Arthus reaction is a rare adverse reaction that usually occurs after vaccination with large and more severe local reactions, belonging to type Ⅲ hypersensitivity reaction. This reaction is characterized by pain, swelling, induration (Tissue that becomes firm) and edema, even accompanied by severe necrosis or ulceration at the injection sites. However, most of mild cases generally can be cured without treatment, and only severe cases need to be treated with anti-allergy. Therefore, this adverse reaction is often ignored by people.We searched PubMed, Web of Science and Chinese database (CNKI database and Wan Fang database) for published studies using the terms "Arthus reaction" or "Arthus phenomenon", combined with "vaccine", with no date or language restrictions for all publications before January 28, 2019. Only 30 cases of Arthus reaction were found, of which only one case died.4 cases of Arthus reaction post-dose-1 were reported in the review. The proportion of Arthus reaction occurred after the first, second and third injections in those case reports was 13.3%, 50.0%, and 23.3%, respectively. Arthus reaction was determined according to the clinical symptoms (The symptoms which were observed by the researchers, such as red, swelling and painful with itching at or around the injection sites). The specific causes of Arthus reaction after one dose of vaccination are not described in detail in literatures. Therefore, it could be hypothesized that the case has a pre-existing specific IgG (Such as pre-existing antibody, etc.) to cause the Arthus reaction.And 17 reported cases were observed in children younger than 6 y. In addition, we collected only 18 cases of bacterial vaccine-induced Arthus reaction and 12 cases of viral vaccines. However, there are no other data (Such as the total number and incidence rate of vaccination) in literatures, so we cannot compare statistically significant differences. At presents, no previous reviews of vaccine-induced Arthus reaction have been found. Thus, a systematic review about vaccine-associated Arthus reaction is urgently needed to deepen people's understanding and concern of this phenomenon. In this manuscript, we retrospectively reviewed the description of the discovery process and mechanisms of Arthus reaction, a description of the characteristics of Arthus reaction cases, reporting the Arthus reaction cases in China during 2010-2015, diagnostic criteria and general treatment, preventive measures of Arthus reaction, and challenges remaining to be investigated in the future.
阿瑟反应是一种罕见的不良反应,通常在大剂量和更严重的局部反应疫苗接种后发生,属于Ⅲ型超敏反应。这种反应的特征是疼痛、肿胀、硬结(组织变硬)和水肿,甚至在注射部位伴有严重的坏死或溃疡。然而,大多数轻症病例通常无需治疗即可治愈,只有重症病例才需要抗过敏治疗。因此,这种不良反应往往被人们忽视。我们检索了 PubMed、Web of Science 和中国数据库(CNKI 数据库和万方数据库),使用“阿瑟反应”或“阿瑟现象”和“疫苗”等术语,对 2019 年 1 月 28 日之前所有出版物进行了无日期和语言限制的搜索。仅发现 30 例阿瑟反应病例,其中仅 1 例死亡。综述中报道了 4 例 1 剂后阿瑟反应。在这些病例报告中,首次、第二次和第三次注射后发生阿瑟反应的比例分别为 13.3%、50.0%和 23.3%。阿瑟反应是根据临床症状(研究者观察到的症状,如注射部位或周围的红肿、肿胀和瘙痒)确定的。文献中没有详细描述单次接种疫苗后发生阿瑟反应的确切原因。因此,可以假设该病例存在预先存在的特定 IgG(如预先存在的抗体等),导致阿瑟反应。并且 17 例报告的病例发生在 6 岁以下的儿童中。此外,我们仅收集了 18 例细菌性疫苗引起的阿瑟反应和 12 例病毒性疫苗引起的阿瑟反应。然而,文献中没有其他数据(如接种总数和发病率),因此我们无法进行统计学上的显著差异比较。目前,尚未发现疫苗引起的阿瑟反应的先前综述。因此,迫切需要对疫苗相关性阿瑟反应进行系统评价,以加深人们对这一现象的认识和关注。在本文中,我们回顾性地综述了阿瑟反应的发现过程和机制的描述、阿瑟反应病例的特征描述、报告 2010-2015 年期间中国的阿瑟反应病例、诊断标准和一般治疗、阿瑟反应的预防措施,以及未来仍需研究的挑战。