Department of Oncology, Division of Radiation Oncology, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Department of Radiation and Cellular Oncology, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2019 Jul 15;104(4):773-777. doi: 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2019.03.042. Epub 2019 Apr 3.
Radiation oncology is often overlooked in US medical school curricula, with few opportunities for most students to learn about the specialty or the value of radiation therapy in cancer care. Tumor boards represent a potential avenue not only to increase students' exposure to radiation oncologists but also to provide a fundamental understanding of the multidisciplinary nature of cancer care and effective collaboration in clinical practice.
In this study, we evaluated a novel radiation oncologist-driven tumor board shadowing experience at 3 medical schools in the United States and Canada. A total of 323 first- and second-year medical students participated, of whom 77.4% completed a follow-up survey assessing the effectiveness of the program as a learning tool.
Compared with traditional clinical shadowing, students were more likely to believe that tumor board shadowing provided a similar or better experience in terms of educational content (85%), exposure to a new field (96%), and overall experience (89%). Forty-eight percent of students perceived a greater amount of multidisciplinary collaboration in oncologic care than they thought existed prior to attending. Forty-eight percent of students also felt more competent interacting with oncologists after participating, whereas 21% felt more competent interacting with patients with cancer. Students' perception of increased competence was correlated with the amount of time their assigned physician mentor spent answering their questions after the tumor board (P < .01). Second-year medical students also had a more favorable overall experience than first-year medical students did (P = .04).
Multidisciplinary tumor boards can be used effectively as a unique immersive learning opportunity that can be feasibly implemented to improve knowledge of clinical oncology and multidisciplinary care in medical schools and expose students to physicians in smaller fields such as radiation oncology.
放射肿瘤学在美国医学院课程中经常被忽视,大多数学生几乎没有机会了解该专业或放射治疗在癌症治疗中的价值。肿瘤委员会不仅代表了增加学生接触放射肿瘤学家的机会,而且还提供了对癌症治疗多学科性质和临床实践中有效协作的基本理解。
在这项研究中,我们评估了美国和加拿大的 3 所医学院中一种新型的放射肿瘤学家驱动的肿瘤委员会影子体验。共有 323 名一年级和二年级医学生参与了该研究,其中 77.4%完成了一项后续调查,评估了该计划作为学习工具的有效性。
与传统的临床影子体验相比,学生更有可能认为肿瘤委员会影子体验在教育内容(85%)、接触新领域(96%)和整体体验(89%)方面提供了类似或更好的体验。48%的学生认为肿瘤学护理中的多学科协作比他们在参加之前认为的要多。48%的学生在参与后感到与肿瘤学家的互动更有能力,而 21%的学生感到与癌症患者的互动更有能力。学生对增加能力的感知与他们的主治医生导师在肿瘤委员会后回答他们问题的时间有关(P<.01)。与一年级医学生相比,二年级医学生的整体体验也更为良好(P=.04)。
多学科肿瘤委员会可以作为一种独特的沉浸式学习机会有效地使用,以提高医学院学生对临床肿瘤学和多学科护理的知识,并使学生接触到较小领域的医生,如放射肿瘤学。