UKCRC Centre for Diet and Activity Research (CEDAR), MRC Epidemiology Unit, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 0QQ, UK.
MRC/Wits Developmental Pathways for Health Research Unit (DPHRU), Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg 1862, South Africa.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2019 Apr 4;16(7):1212. doi: 10.3390/ijerph16071212.
Childhood obesity is of increasing concern in many parts of Africa. We conducted a systematic search and review of published literature on behavioural childhood obesity prevention interventions. A literature search identified peer-reviewed literature from seven databases, and unindexed African journals, including experimental studies targeting children age 2-18 years in African countries, published in any language since 1990. All experimental designs were eligible; outcomes of interest were both behavioural (physical activity, dietary behaviours) and anthropometric (weight, body mass index, body composition). We also searched for process evaluations or other implementation observations. Methodological quality was assessed; evidence was synthesised narratively as a meta-analysis was not possible. Seventeen articles describing 14 interventions in three countries (South Africa, Tunisia and Uganda) were included. Effect scores indicated no overall effect on dietary behaviours, with some beneficial effects on physical activity and anthropometric outcomes. The quality of evidence was predominantly weak. We identified barriers and facilitators to successful interventions, and these were largely resource-related. Our systematic review highlights research gaps in targeting alternative settings to schools, and younger age groups, and a need for more rigorous designs for evaluating effectiveness. We also recommend process evaluations being used more widely.
儿童肥胖在非洲的许多地区越来越令人关注。我们对已发表的关于行为儿童肥胖预防干预的文献进行了系统的搜索和综述。文献搜索确定了来自七个数据库和未编入索引的非洲期刊的同行评议文献,包括针对非洲国家 2-18 岁儿童的实验研究,这些研究于 1990 年以来以任何语言发表。所有实验设计都符合条件;感兴趣的结果包括行为(身体活动、饮食行为)和人体测量学(体重、体重指数、身体成分)。我们还搜索了针对过程评估或其他实施观察的文献。评估了方法学质量;由于不可能进行荟萃分析,因此以叙述性方式综合证据。有 17 篇文章描述了三个国家(南非、突尼斯和乌干达)的 14 项干预措施。效应评分表明,饮食行为没有总体影响,但对身体活动和人体测量学结果有一些有益影响。证据质量主要较弱。我们确定了成功干预的障碍和促进因素,这些因素主要与资源有关。我们的系统综述突出了针对学校以外的替代环境和年龄较小的群体的研究差距,以及需要更严格的设计来评估有效性。我们还建议更广泛地使用过程评估。