Dolev Niva, Goldental Nadav, Reuven-Lelong Ayalla, Tadmor Tamar
School of Humanities, Kinneret Academic College, Tzemach, Israel.
The Ruth & Bruce Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
Rambam Maimonides Med J. 2019 Apr 18;10(2):e0010. doi: 10.5041/RMMJ.10365.
The importance of emotional intelligence (EI) to the success of health professionals has been increasingly acknowledged. Concurrently, medical schools have begun integrating non-cognitive measures in candidate selection processes. The question remains whether these newly added processes correctly assess EI skills.
Measuring EI levels among medical students; examining the correlations between participants' EI levels and their scores on the non-cognitive MOR test; and exploring students' attitudes regarding the importance of EI in medical practice.
The study included 111 first-year and sixth-year students at the Faculty of Medicine at the Technion, Haifa, Israel. Emotional intelligence was assessed by the Bar-On EQ-i 2.0, and MOR evaluation scores were provided by the faculty. An additional questionnaire was designed to rate students' attitudes toward the importance of EI to the success of medical doctors (MDs).
No significant correlations were found between MOR test scores and EI evaluation scores. Of the 15 EI competencies evaluated, mean scores for flexibility, problem-solving, and independence were lowest for both the first-year and the sixth-year study groups. No differences in EI levels between first-year and sixth-year students were found. Both groups of students considered EI to be highly important to their success as MDs.
While further studies of the links between MOR tests and EI are required, the current findings indicate that MOR test scores may not be predictive of medical students' EI levels and vice versa. As previous evidence suggests that EI contributes to professional success and to better outcomes in the field of medicine, integrating it into selection processes for medical students and into the curricula in medical schools is recommended.
情商(EI)对健康专业人员成功的重要性已得到越来越多的认可。与此同时,医学院校已开始在候选人选拔过程中纳入非认知测评。问题仍然是这些新增加的过程是否能正确评估情商技能。
测量医学生的情商水平;检查参与者的情商水平与其在非认知MOR测试中的分数之间的相关性;并探讨学生对情商在医学实践中的重要性的态度。
该研究纳入了以色列海法理工学院医学院的111名一年级和六年级学生。通过巴昂情商问卷(Bar-On EQ-i 2.0)评估情商,MOR评估分数由教师提供。另外设计了一份问卷来评估学生对情商对医生成功的重要性的态度。
未发现MOR测试分数与情商评估分数之间存在显著相关性。在评估的15项情商能力中,一年级和六年级研究组的灵活性、解决问题能力和独立性的平均得分最低。一年级和六年级学生的情商水平没有差异。两组学生都认为情商对他们成为医生的成功非常重要。
虽然需要进一步研究MOR测试与情商之间的联系,但目前的研究结果表明,MOR测试分数可能无法预测医学生的情商水平,反之亦然。正如先前的证据表明情商有助于职业成功和在医学领域取得更好的成果,建议将其纳入医学生的选拔过程和医学院校的课程中。