Kalaitzi Stavroula, Czabanowska Katarzyna, Azzopardi-Muscat Natasha, Cuschieri Liliana, Petelos Elena, Papadakaki Maria, Babich Suzanne
Department of International Health, Care and Public Health Research Institute (CAPHRI), Faculty of Health, Medicine and Life Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, the Netherlands,
Department of Health Policy and Management, Institute of Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, Jagellonian University, Krakow, Poland.
J Healthc Leadersh. 2019 Apr 12;11:43-59. doi: 10.2147/JHL.S194733. eCollection 2019.
Women leaders encounter societal and cultural challenges that define and diminish their career potential. This occurs across several professions including healthcare. Scant attention has been drawn to the discursive dynamics among gender, healthcare leadership and societal culture. The aim of this study is to assess empirically gendered barriers to women's leadership in healthcare through the lens of sociocultural characteristics. The comparative study was conducted in Greece and Malta. The interest in these countries stems from their poor performance in the gender employment gap and the rapid sociocultural and economic changes occurring in the European-Mediterranean region.
Thirty-six individual in-depth interviews were conducted with health-care leaders, including both women and men (18 women and 18 men). Directed content analysis was used to identify and analyze themes against the coding scheme of the Barriers Thematic Map to women's leadership. Summative content analysis was applied to quantify the usage of themes, while qualitative meta-summative method was used to interpret and contextualize the findings.
Twenty and twenty-one barriers to women's leadership were identified within the Greek and Maltese healthcare settings, respectively. Prevailing barriers included work/life balance, lack of family (spousal) support, culture, stereotypes, gender bias and lack of social support. Inter-country similarities and differences in prevalence of the identified barriers were observed.
The study appraised empirically the gendered barriers that women encounter in healthcare leadership through the lens of national sociocultural specificities. Findings unveiled underlying interactions among gender, leadership and countries' sociocultural contexts, which may elucidate the varying degrees of strength of norms and barriers embedded in a society's egalitarian practices. Cultural tightness has been found to be experienced by societal dividends as an alibi or barrier against sociocultural transformation. Findings informed a conceptual framework proposed to advance research in the area of women's leadership.
女性领导者面临着界定并削弱其职业潜力的社会和文化挑战。这在包括医疗保健在内的多个职业领域都存在。性别、医疗保健领导力和社会文化之间的话语动态很少受到关注。本研究的目的是通过社会文化特征的视角,实证评估女性在医疗保健领域担任领导职务时面临的性别障碍。这项比较研究在希腊和马耳他进行。对这些国家的兴趣源于它们在性别就业差距方面的糟糕表现,以及欧洲 - 地中海地区正在发生的快速社会文化和经济变化。
对医疗保健领导者进行了36次个人深度访谈,包括女性和男性(18名女性和18名男性)。采用定向内容分析法,根据女性领导力障碍主题地图的编码方案识别和分析主题。运用总结性内容分析法对主题的使用情况进行量化,同时采用定性元总结法对研究结果进行解释和背景化。
在希腊和马耳他的医疗保健环境中,分别确定了20个和21个女性领导力障碍。普遍存在的障碍包括工作与生活的平衡、缺乏家庭(配偶)支持、文化、刻板印象、性别偏见以及缺乏社会支持。观察到所确定障碍的发生率在国家间存在异同。
本研究通过国家社会文化特殊性的视角,实证评估了女性在医疗保健领导力中遇到的性别障碍。研究结果揭示了性别、领导力和国家社会文化背景之间的潜在相互作用,这可能阐明社会平等实践中规范和障碍的不同强度程度。研究发现文化紧密性被社会红利视为社会文化变革的借口或障碍。研究结果为推进女性领导力领域研究的概念框架提供了参考。