Azaad Shaheed, Laham Simon M
Melbourne School of Psychological Sciences, The University of Melbourne, Parkville, VIC, Australia.
Q J Exp Psychol (Hove). 2019 Nov;72(11):2605-2613. doi: 10.1177/1747021819852216. Epub 2019 May 31.
Tucker and Ellis found that when participants made left/right button-presses to indicate whether objects were upright or inverted, responses were faster when the response hand aligned with the task-irrelevant handle orientation of the object. The effect of handle orientation on response times has been interpreted as evidence that individuals perceive grasp when viewing briefly presented objects, which in turn activate grasp-related motor systems. Although the effect of handle alignment has since been replicated, there remains doubt regarding the extent to which the effect is indeed driven by affordance perception. Objects that feature in affordance-compatibility paradigms are asymmetrical and have laterally protruding handles (e.g., mugs) and thus confound spatial and affordance properties. Research has attempted to disentangle spatial compatibility and affordance effects with varying results. In this study, we present a novel paradigm with which to study affordance perception while sidestepping spatial confounds. We use the Bimanual Affordance Task (BMAT) to test whether object affordances in symmetrical objects facilitate response times. Participants ( = 36) used one of three (left unimanual/right unimanual/bimanual) responses to indicate the colour of presented objects. Objects afforded either a unimanual (e.g., handbag) or a bimanual (e.g., laundry hamper) grasp. Responses were faster when the afforded grasp corresponded with the response type (unimanual vs. bimanual), suggesting that affordance effects exist independent of spatial compatibility.
塔克和埃利斯发现,当参与者通过左右按键来表明物体是正立还是倒置时,若反应手与物体不相关的把手方向一致,反应会更快。把手方向对反应时间的影响被解释为个体在观看短暂呈现的物体时会感知到抓握,这进而激活了与抓握相关的运动系统。尽管此后把手对齐的效应得到了重复验证,但对于该效应在多大程度上确实由可供性感知驱动仍存在疑问。在可供性兼容范式中出现的物体是不对称的,且有侧向突出的把手(如杯子),因此混淆了空间和可供性属性。研究试图区分空间兼容性和可供性效应,但结果各异。在本研究中,我们提出了一种新颖的范式,用于在避开空间混淆的同时研究可供性感知。我们使用双手可供性任务(BMAT)来测试对称物体中的物体可供性是否会促进反应时间。参与者(n = 36)使用三种反应方式之一(左手单手/右手单手/双手)来表明所呈现物体的颜色。物体提供单手(如手提包)或双手(如洗衣篮)抓握方式。当提供的抓握方式与反应类型(单手对双手)相匹配时,反应更快,这表明可供性效应独立于空间兼容性而存在。